Probe design

Figure 1 outlines the concept for the design of the probes targeting oral lactobacilli. Two broad Lactobacillus probes (LGC358a and LAB759) were generated with the idea that they should complement each other and thus limit the potential of misidentifications [7]. Elongated by one and shifted by four bases LGC358a is a derivative of probe LGC354a [13]. Probes LGC358b (staphylococci and related bacteria) and LGC358c (streptococci) are analogously related to LGC354b and LGC354c described by Meier et al. [13]. As observed often with probes to larger phylogenetic groups, initial experiments with both probes detected besides the targeted lactobacilli significant numbers of false positives (predominantly cocci) when applied to oral plaque samples (see below). In silico analyses suggested that these false hybridizations were due to single sequence mismatches and could possibly be avoided by the application of unlabeled competitor probes that are fully complimentary to the targeted 16S rRNA segment of the false positive organisms. Applied in excess together with the labeled FISH probe such competitor probes can increase the differentiation between true- and potential false positives [14]. Thus, LGC358a used in conjunction with LGC358b-comp should recognize selectively most Lactobacillaceae organisms and in addition detect parts of the non-oral families Leuconostocaceae and Carnobacteriaceae, whereas LAB759, when applied together with LAB759-comp (which should suppress recognition of Streptococcus mutans as well as Eikenella, Kingella, and Neisseria sp.) is supposed to identify all oral lactobacilli except Lactobacillus salivarius and the majority of L. fermentum strains. Application of these competitor probes to various types of plaques samples proved to be successful in providing specificity for lactobacilli (see below). The other probes for lactobacilli were designed to identify bacteria from all major deep branching clusters of the phylogenic tree (Figure 1). Three probes recognize deeply branched, individual species (L. fermentum, L. salivarius and Lactobacillus vaginalis), which, however, belong to the most frequently detected oral lactobacilli. Probes recognizing oral Granulicatella and Abtiotrophia species (ABI161 and ABI1246), Lactococcus lactis (LCC1030) and cocci belonging to Streptococcus constellatus/Streptococcus intermedius (L-Sco/int172-2) or Streptococcus sobrinus (L-Ssob440) complement the set of new probes.

Permeabilization of lactobacilli for FISH

Uniform permeabilization for FISH of fixed lactobacilli (but not of streptococci or Abiotrophia/Granulicatella) is a known problem [9], in particular with certain 'notorious' strains. Like other authors before, we have evaluated several permeabilization protocols that precede hybridization and obtained the best results with a modification of a procedure proposed by Harmsen et al. [9] (data not shown). It was applied selectively to all Lactobacillus probes and consists of a 5 min exposure to lysozyme and achromopeptidase, followed by a 30 min incubation with lipase.

Fluorescence intensity and probe specificity

Lactobacillus probes were tested with 22 reference strains representing the different oral lactobacilli clusters as described by the HOMD (Table 2) and, with the exceptions of probe LAB759 and Lfer466, displayed the anticipated reactivity profile. As an example Figure 2A shows the staining of Lactobacillus rhamnosus AC 413 with Lcas467-Cy3. Pointing at one of the strengths of single cell analyses with FISH, strain Lactobacillus crispatus ATCC 33820 was found contaminated with L. fermentum and required recloning (Figure 2B). With several probes the fluorescence intensity was weak but could be significantly improved by adding non-fluorescent helper probes to the hybridization solution [15], or by employing probes containing locked-nucleic-acids (LNA) [16]. The former bind to regions of the 16S rRNA that are adjacent to the target sequence thereby contributing to the opening of the rRNA's 3-D structure and improving probe accessibility, whereas the latter contain one or two derivative nucleotide analogs with their ribose locked in a C3'-endo conformation which leads to a higher target selectivity of the probe. Unexpected from in silico data, LAB759 labeled the L. salivarius reference strain ATCC 11741 and Lfer466 bound to the Lactobacillus reuteri type strain CCUG 33624^T. The reasons for these exceptional hybridizations remain to be determined. Generally, the LNA-probes yielded high fluorescence intensity but also required high formamide concentrations to display the predicted specificity. In particular, L-Lbre466 was cross-reactive with Lactobacillus colehominis and L-Lbuc438 was cross-reactive with some strains of both the L. casei and L. reuteri clusters if the formamide concentration was kept below 45%. Similarly, the L-Lcol732 probe was false positive with strains from the Lactobacillus buchneri cluster at < 40% formamide. Of the other probes listed in Table 1, ABI1246 was strongly positive with all four Abiotrophia/Granulicatella reference strains tested (Granulicatella adjacens CCUG 27809^T and HE-G-R 613A, Granulicatella elegans CCUG 38949^T and Abiotrophia defectiva CCUG 36937), whereas ABI161 labeled only the Granulicatella strains. Probe LCC1030 was positive with Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis reference strain NCC2211 [17], and the S. mutans and S. sobrinus probes Smut590 and L-Lsob440 stained reference strains UA159^T and OMZ 176, respectively, while none of the probes was positive with strains from other streptococcal species. Probe L-Ssob440-2 yielded better fluorescence intensity than the previously described probe SOB174 [10], but had to be used at high stringency. All these findings were as expected from in silico data.

		16S rRNA probes
Group, Strain	OMZ	LGC358a	LAB759 + LABB759-comp	Lpla759	Lpla990 + H1018	L-Lbre466-2	L-Lbuc438-2	Lcas467	Lsal574	L-Lsal1113-2	Lreu986 + H1018	Lfer466 + H448+ H484	L-Lcol732-2	Lvag222	Lgas458	Lgas183
L. buchneri et rel.
L. plantarum FAM 1638	945	2-4+*,a	3-4+	3-4+	2-4+*	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-
L. brevis ATCC 14869	625	3-4 +	2-3 +	-	-	4+	-	-	-	-	-	±	-b	-	-	-
L. brevis OMZ 1114	1114	2-4+	2-3+*	-	-	3-4+	-	-	-	-	-	-	-b	-	-	-
L. buchneri ATCC 4005	626	2-4 +	1-2 +	-	-	-	3-4 +	-	-	-	-	-	-b	-	-	-
L. buchneri	1097	2-4 +*	2-3 +*	-	-	-	3+	-	-	-	-	-	-b	-	-	-
L. casei et rel.
L. casei ATCC 393	939	2-4+	3-4+	-	-	-	-c	3+	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-
L. casei Cl-16	638	3-4 +	3-4 +	-	-	-	-c	3-4 +	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-
L. paracasei ATCC 25598	624	2-4 +*	2-4 +*	-	-	-	-c	3-4 +*	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-
L. rhamnosus AC 413	629	2-4 +	2-4 +	-	-	-	-	3-4 +	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-
L. rhamnosus ATCC 7469T	602	2-4 +	2-4 +	-	-	-	-	3 +	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-
L. salivarius
L. salivarius ATCC 11741	525	3-4+	3-4+	-	-	-	-	-	2-4+	3-4+	±	-	-	-	-	-
L. salivarius OMZ 1115	1115	2-4+	-	-	-	-	-	-	3-4+	3-4+	-	-	-	-	-	-
L. reuteri et rel.
L. coleohominis DSM14060T	1113	1-3 +	2-4 +	-	-	-d	-	-	-	-	3 +	-	3-4 +	-	-	-
L. fermentum ATCC 14931	524	2-4 +*	2 +*, e	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	2-4 +	3-4 +	-	-	-	-
L. fermentum OMZ 1116	1116	2-4 +	2 +*, e	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	2-4 +	3-4 +	-	-	-	-
L. reuteri CCUG 33624T	1100	2-4 +	3-4 +	-	-	-	-c	±	-	-	2-4 +	2-4 +	-	-	-	-
L. vaginalis UMCG 5837	1095	2-4 +	3-4 +	-	-	-	-c	-	-	-	1-3 +*	-	-	3-4 +	-	-
L. gasseri et rel.
L. acidophilus ATCC 4357	523	2-4+	3-4+	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	±	±	-	-	2-4+	-
L. crispatus ATCC 33820	522	3-4 +	3-4 +	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-		-	-	3-4 +	-
L. gasseri ATCC 19992	520	2-4 +	2-4 +	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	±	1 +	-	-	1-3 +	2-4 +
L. gasseri OMZ 549	549	2-4 +	2-4 +	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	±	-	-	-	2-4 +	2-4 +
L. jensenii UMCG 20557	1096	2-4 +	3-4 +	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-

* The asterisk indicates that only a small percentage of the cells could be stained by the probe, in spite of enzymatic pretreatment to improve probe penetration.

^a Fluorescence intensity was graded using an arbitrary five-step scale, where - (no fluorescence above background) and 1+ (very faint fluorescence) were considered negative signals, and 2+ (weak), 3+ (strong) and 4+ (brilliant fluorescence) were considered positive signals.

^b Probe L-Lcol732-2 labeled L. brevis and L. buchneri strains at formamide concentrations below 40%.

^c L-Lbuc438-2 cross-reacted with certain strains from the L. casei and L. reuteri groups at formamide concentrations of ≤ 45%.

^d L-Lbre466-2 was positive with L. coleohominis at ≤ 45% formamide in the hybridization buffer.

^e L. fermentum was stained with low intensity due to a weak mismatch at position 760.

Enumeration of lactic acid bacteria from in situ formed biofilms

The applicability of the probes was tested with three in situ formed biofilm samples. The samples were harvested from bovine enamel discs carried in acrylic appliances on the buccal side of the mandibular premolar/molar regions [18] by three volunteers whose discs differed greatly in the extent of demineralization (-3%, -15%, and -32%) generated during the 10 days of intermittent extraoral exposure to a 5% glucose/5% sucrose solution. All samples were positive for lactobacilli as detected by the two broadly reactive Lactobacillus probes LGC358a and LAB759 (Figure 3). Total cell numbers and numbers of lactobacilli were very similar to findings from an earlier study investigating the microbiota associated with the in situ development of caries [19]. Both probes had to be used imperatively together with their respective competitor probes, since, without them, large numbers of cocci and other morphotypes were positive. In the biofilm from disc 013 (biofilm 013 in the following) LGC358a stained clearly two populations of rods that differed in length, whereas LAB759 identified only the shorter of the two morphotypes. The longer and predominant cell type had the probe reactivity profile LGC358a⁺/LAB759^-/Lfer466⁺/Lreu986⁺/Lcas467^- (Figure 2C), whereas the smaller one was LGC358a⁺/LAB759⁺/Lfer466^-/Lreu986^-/Lcas467⁺, indicating that the larger rods are L. fermentum and the smaller ones lactobacilli from the casei group. While the total number of L. casei, streptococci or Abiotrophia/Granulicatella seemed not to correlate with the extent of disc demineralization, the high concentration of L. fermentum in the biofilm of the extremely demineralized disc 013 was quite remarkable.

All other lactobacillus probes gave negative results. Concerning Lsal574 and Lvag222 we found that both these probes had to be used at much higher stringency conditions (50% formamide) than expected from the in vitro experiments with reference strains to prevent cross-reactivity with other biofilm bacteria. In particular cells with the characteristic morphology of Selenomonas were often cross-reactive at conditions of insufficient stringency. Abiotrophia and Granulicatella could be detected in high numbers in all three samples. Both ABI161 and ABI1246 recognized cocci, which in double-labeling experiments stained always negative with the streptococcal probes LGC358c and MIT447 (data not shown). Finally, all samples contained high numbers of streptococci, mostly from the mitis group. S. mutans, however, was found with MUT590 in only one sample at low concentration, and the probes for S. sobrinus and S. constellatus/S. intermedius gave negative results. Identification by FISH of streptococci, in particular of the mitis group, is hindered severely by high conservation of the 16S rRNA gene sequence among these taxa [20, 21] and therefore FISH detection of oral streptococci still relies mostly on phylogenic group-specific probes. A surprise finding, confirmed with supragingival plaque samples and scrapings from the dorsum of the tongue, was that both Lactococcus probe LCC1030 and S. constellatus/intermedius probe L-Sco/int172-2 triggered rather strong fluorescence of long filaments with blunted ends (Figure 2D), which could only be suppressed by applying formamide concentrations exceeding 40%. The results were confirmed when probes with exchanged fluorescence labels were used (Cy3 instead of 6-FAM and vice versa). Potential specificity problems associated with phylogenetic group-specific probes are a known phenomenon [7, 22]. However, screening of the RDP10 database for oral bacteria with this type of morphology and ≤ 2 sequence mismatches within the gene fragments complementary to these probes, failed to reveal any hints about the possible identity of these filaments. Experiments aiming at their isolation by fluorescence activated cell sorting are ongoing.

Typing of Lactobacillus isolates from in situ grown oral biofilms

Critical importance of several assay parameters

Lactobacilli are difficult targets for FISH because of their cell wall's resistance to probe penetration. The protocol used successfully in the present study to increase cell permeability evolved from the method of Harmsen et al.[9], which we supplemented with achromopeptidase, previously described to open cell walls of Actinomyces strains [23, 24]. Systematic evaluation of this three-enzyme-pretreatment with 12 reference strains from seven Lactobacillus species showed its indispensability. However, a minority of strains proved to be particularly resistant, as up to 20% of the cells recognizable by phase contrast could not be stained. Of course this raised concerns that such false-negative results could also affect analyses of clinical samples. We cannot completely rule out this possibility, but after comprehensive analysis of many plaque samples we would like to hypothesize that there are differences in cell wall permeability between cultured and native lactobacilli and that false-negative cells are primarily seen after FISH with cultured lactobacilli.

With cell wall permeability remaining a potential reason for concern, maximum fluorescence intensity from penetrated probes is essential. Fluorescence intensity depends on cellular ribosome content, in situ probe accessibility to the probe target region, and rRNA stability [25]. Several procedures to maximize the performance of FISH probes have been described [15, 16, 26, 27]. They alter the 3-dimensional structure of the target region by using helper probes, optimize probe length and hybridization conditions, improve binding affinity by modifying the probes' backbone with LNA substitutions, or inhibit enzymatic rRNA degradation. In this study we used all four procedures to improve fluorescence intensity of certain probes. For Lfer466, Lreu986, and Lpla990 one or two helper probes binding directly adjacent to the target site were added to the hybridization solution and in each case a clear-cut improvement of fluorescence intensity was observed. The same was the case when the LNA-substituted probe L-Ssob440-2 was compared to Ssob440. For five other probes the decision to opt for LNA insertions was taken solely based on own and published experience [25], suggesting limited accessibility of the probes' target site. All these LNA/DNA-probes displayed intensive fluorescence, but required strict adherence of very stringent hybridization conditions for sufficient specificity.

Strains, plaque samples and in situ grown biofilms

Lactobacillus reference strains (listed in Table 2) were grown in 10% CO₂ at 37 °C on LBS (Lactobacillus selection) agar and in LBS broth (Becton Dickinson). Lactococcus, Streptococcus, Abiotrophia and Granulicatella reference strains from the OMZ strain collection were propagated anaerobically on Columbia blood agar or in fluid universal medium [28]. They were harvested after 24-36 h during the late log-phase of growth. Supragingival plaque samples and scrapings from the dorsum of the tongue were collected from two of the authors, washed in 0.9% NaCl, fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde/PBS (20 min, 4 °C), and stored in 50% ethanol at -20 °C.

In situ grown biofilm samples were harvested from bovine enamel discs (6.8 mm Ø) carried for 10 days and nights by three volunteers in the course of a double-blind split-mouth de- and remineralization study carried out at the University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway [18]. The Regional Committee for Medical Research Ethics Western Norway approved the study protocol and the volunteers gave their informed written consent to participate in the study. Inclusion criteria for volunteers were normal salivary flow and a full dentition without non-restored caries lesions or evidence of moderate or severe gingivitis. Antibiotics, mouth rinses or tooth pastes containing antimicrobial agents (e.g. chlorhexidine, triclosan, SnF₂, Zn²⁺, etc.) or drugs affecting the salivary flow rate should not have been used for the last three months. The appliances were kept in 0.9% NaCl during meals and tooth cleaning; in addition they were dipped seven times daily for 10 min in 5% glucose/5% sucrose solution to promote plaque formation. After 10 days in the oral cavity of the volunteers, the discs were removed from the appliances and the biofilms were harvested by scraping with plastic scalers (ZI 10; Deppeler, Rolle, Switzerland) into approximately 1 ml of sterile 0.9% NaCl as collecting fluid (exact volume determined for each sample). The samples were frozen at -80 °C and shipped to Zürich on dry ice for further analyses. There, freshly defrosted samples were vortexted for 1 min, sonicated for 5 s, aliquoted and assessed by FISH. Aliquots were also grown at 37 °C anaerobically and in 10% CO₂ on LBS agar (Becton Dickinson) with the aim to isolate and type representative strains by partial 16S rDNA sequencing. Demineralization of discs was determined by quantitative light-induced fluorescence as described [29].

Preparation of multi-well slides for FISH

Overnight cultures of lactobacilli (LBS broth) were washed in 0.9% NaCl, diluted in coating buffer [30], spotted on 18- or 24-well slides (Cel-Line Associates), air-dried, and fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde/PBS (20 min, 4 °C). Analogously, in situ grown biofilm samples, supragingival plaque samples and tongue scrapings were vortexed at maximum speed for 60 s, diluted in coating buffer and coated to 18- or 24-well slides as described [30]. To improve cell wall permeability each well selected for FISH of lactobacilli was treated individually at room temperature first for 5 min with 9 μl of lysozyme (1 mg ml^-1; Sigma-Aldrich L-7651) and achromopeptidase (1 mg ml^-1; Sigma-Aldrich A-7550) in Tris-HCl (pH 7.5) with 5 mM EDTA, and then for 30 min with 9 μ l of lipase (Sigma-Aldrich L-1754; at 25 mg ml^-1 in water the lipase suspension was centrifuged for 5 min at 16'000 × g after which the supernatant was used). Thereafter, to limit unspecific FISH probe binding all wells were covered for 30 min at 37 °C with 9 μ l of PBS containing Denhardt's solution (Fluka 30915; diluted 1:50) in the presence of protectRNA RNase inhibitor (Sigma-Aldrich R-7397; diluted 1:500) [15, 16, 26, 27]. At the end of the respective incubation periods the solutions were carefully aspirated and the slides briefly washed in wash-buffer (0.9% NaCl, 0.05% Tween 20, 0.01% NaN₃), dipped in water, and air-dried. All solutions were made with water of nano-pure quality.

Fluorescent in situ hybridization

The 16S rRNA targeted oligonucleotide probes used in this study are listed in Table 1. Custom-synthesized by Microsynth, they were labeled at 5'-end with Cy3 or 6-FAM, or in some cases at both ends with 6-FAM. Probes marked by "L-" in front of the probe name, contain one or two LNA to improve in situ hybridization efficiency [16]. Probes were designed as described previously [30] using the ARB software [31] with the SILVA rRNA database [32, 33] and additional rRNA sequence information from 'The Ribosomal Data Base Project II' [34, 35] and the 'National Center for Biotechnology Information' [36]. Probes LGC358a and LAB759 had to be used in conjunction with a competitor probe to suppress cross-reactivity with taxa other than lactobacilli and few probes were used together with helper probes [15] to improve fluorescence intensity (Table 1). Probes were used at final concentrations of 5 ng μ l^-1 (Cy3 conjugates) or 15 ng μ l^-1 (FAM conjugates, competitor and helper probes). EUB338 served as positive control. FISH was performed as described [30] using hybridization times of 2 or 4 h and probe-specific formamide concentrations as listed in Table 1. Optimum formamide concentrations were determined by varying the formamide concentrations systematically between 25% and 55% in FISH experiments with both reference strains and oral biofilm samples.

Scoring and enumeration of stained bacteria

Following FISH, air-dried multiwell slides were covered with mounting fluid (90% glycerol in PBS with 25 mg g^-1 1,4-diazabicyclo[2, 2, 2]octan) and cover-slips. Bacteria stained by FISH were enumerated as described using an Olympus BX60 epifluorescence microscope (Olympus Optical [Schweiz]) [30]. Scoring of fluorescence intensity is described in a footnote to Table 2.

16S rDNA sequencing

Partial 16S rRNA gene sequences of five lactobacillus isolates (OMZ 1117-1121) from the three in situ grown biofilms were determined as described previously [35]. The sequences of 1393, 1360, 1366, 1371 and 1379 bp in length were compared to gene bank data of the The Ribosomal Data Base Project using the Seq Match algorithm [33]. Identification of isolates was based on ≥ 99.5% similarity. The sequences of OMZ 1117 - 1119 were deposited at EMBL with accession numbers FR667951 - FR667953.