A Blue Native-PAGE analysis of membrane protein complexes in Clostridium thermocellum

Preparation of Membrane Protein Samples

Purification of protein complexes in an intact form (i.e. complete with all peripherally associated proteins) is largely dependent on the solubilization conditions used and can differ for various complexes. By testing four commonly used detergents at different concentrations (see "Methods"), we were able to select a protocol using the detergent n-dodecyl-D-maltoside (DDM). This protocol detected a number of complexes in the molecular mass range from 60 to over 1,000 kDa. The molecular mass of protein complexes was calculated by plotting the MWs of marker proteins against their migration distances.

To identify the individual proteins in each complex, the one-dimensional BN gel strips were analyzed in the second dimension by SDS-PAGE, Figure 1. Putative complexes were consequently resolved into vertical "channels" enabling visualization of the individual constituents. Proteins that had formed a complex in the BN gel were tentatively recognized by their locations on a vertical line on the SDS gel, and also by their similar shapes on the SDS gel (as a result of co-migration in the BN gel).

Protein Identification

Complexes in energy production and conversion

In prokaryotes, three evolutionarily related sub types of ATPases/synthases were found, categorized as F- (F₁-F₀-), V- (V₁-V₀) and A- (A₁-A₀) type ATPases on the basis of their function and taxonomic origins. Although eukaryotes contain both F- and V-ATPases, each highly specialized in its physiological functions; archaea and eubacteria typically contain only one subtype of ATPase [15]. Most eubacteria contain F-ATPases, but some eubacteria contain both F- and V-ATPases, whereas all known archaea contain complexes that are evolutionarily closer to V-ATPases and are referred to as A-ATPases due to their archael origin.

Generally, the F₁-F₀-ATP synthase contains eight subunits arranged in two subcomplexes: F₁ (α₃, β₃, γ, δ, ε) and F₀ (a, b₂, c_10-14) [16]. The V₁-V₀-ATP synthase contains nine subunits arranged in two subcomplexes: V₁ (A₃, B₃, D, F) and V₀ (G, E, C, I, L) [17]. Interestingly, in the genome of C. thermocellum, there are two ATPase gene clusters: a F₁-F₀-ATP synthase (Cthe_2602--Cthe_2609) and V₁-V₀-ATP synthase (Cthe_2261-Cthe_2269), both with a complete set of subunits.

We detected two subunits of F₁-F₀-ATPase, F₁ subunit α (Cthe_2606, 55.8 kDa) and F₁ subunit β (Cthe_2608, 51 kDa), with an estimated molecular mass of 300 kDa and two subunits of V₁-V₀-ATPase, V₁ subunit A (Cthe_2267, 65 kDa) and V₁ subunit B (Cthe_2268, 50 kDa), with an estimated molecular mass of 300 kDa. These may represent a subcomplex of α₃β₃ and A₃B₃ in F1 and V₁, respectively. We conducted a large scale search of ATPase in published genomes of eubacteria from NCBI, 700 genomes were found to contain genes encoding F-type ATPases, 93 genomes contain genes encoding V-type ATPases, and only 44 genomes contain both F-type and V-type ATPases (see Additional file 1). The co-presence of both ATPases in a bacterium is limited to a few genera, which include several Streptococcus, Clostridium, Anaeromyxobacter strains, two Cyanothece species, an Enterococcus faecalis and a Nitrosococcus oceani. We deduce these may reflect unusual ATP generating mechanisms in these bacteria. In this work, we found that both the F- and V-type ATPases are expressed C. themocellum. Co-presence of V- and F-type ATPases in a bacterium is uncommon. Previously, only Enterococcus hirae was reported to utilize both types of ATPases [18]. The E. hirae V-type ATPase differs from typical V-type ATPase in preferentially transporting Na⁺ [19, 20] instead of H⁺. In the thermophilic Clostridium fervidus, a second example of Na⁺-pumping V-type ATPase was reported [21]. It is reasonable to speculate that the V-type ATPase in C. thermocellum is a Na⁺-pumping ATPase. Most bacteria contain either F-type or V-type ATPase, among those that contain both types of ATPases, new functional variants of ATPases could be identified and their roles in bacterial physiology could be investigated.

Bifunctional acetaldehyde/alcohol dehydrogenase (ALDH-ADH, Cthe_0423, 96 kDa) was detected at over 880 kDa. ADHs could be classified into 3 classes based on their length: short chain ADH (approximately 250 residues) and medium chain ADH (approximately 370 residues) exist in a homotetramer form [22], but a structure of long chain ADH (over 380 amino acids and often as many as 900 amino acid residues) was not reported. The ALDH-ADH of C. thermocellum appears to be a long chain ADH and forms a homo-multimer like the ADH in Entamoeba histolytica [23]. Alcohol dehydrogenases were reported to be membrane-bound protein complexes [24–26], it is reasonable to observe ADH in C. thermocellum membrane fraction.

Complexes in lipid transport and metabolism

Carboxyl transferase (CT, Cthe_0699, 56 kDa) was identified at ~220 kDa. In eubacteria, CT is part of acetyl coenzyme A carboxylase (ACC) complex, which normally consists of biotin carboxylase (BC), biotin carboxyl carrier protein (BCCP), and CT. Typically, CT contains two subunits in a stable α₂β₂ form [27, 28]. But, in Streptomyces coelicolor, the ACC enzyme has a subunit (590 residues) with fused BC and BCCP domains, and another subunit (530 residues) that contains the fused CT domains [29]. In archaea, ACC is a multi-subunit enzyme, with BC, BCCP and CT subunits. The archael CT subunit is also a single protein (520 residues) in a CT₄ form, rather than two separate subunits, which is similar to the β subunit (CT) of the ACC from Streptomyces [30]. In C. thermocellum, CT is a 56 kDa protein, which contains two domains of carboxyl transferase, and we did not detect other ACC subunits on BN/SDS-PAGE. So the CT appears to be a sub complex of CT₄ not associated with BC and BCCP. CT was also detected at over 880 kDa, which maybe due to precipitation during electrophoresis or CT formed a large complex with other subunits of ACC. Previous studies also suggested ACC may form a membrane-associated protein complex [31, 32].

Complexes in amino acid transport and metabolism

Serine-Acetyl-Transferase (SAT, Cthe_1840, 33.4 kDa), a subunit of cysteine synthase (CS), was detected at ~130 kDa corresponding to the size of intact CS complex. Typical CS complex is composed of one SAT and two O-Acetyl-Serine-(Thiol)-Lyases (OAS-TL, Cthe_1842, 46.5 kDa) [33, 34], but we did not detect OAS-TL. It is likely that OAS-TL was masked by the very abundant protein, Cthe_1020. Detection of CS in the membrane fractions has been reported in other studies [9, 35].

Ornithine carbamoyltransferase (OTCase, Cthe_1869, 34 kDa) was identified at ~100 kDa, probably in a typical homo-trimer form [36–39]. Some studies suggest that OTCase is a cell surface protein [40, 41] whereas Shi et al. [42] reported that OTCase maybe a membrane-associated protein based on sequence analyses. Our results support the membrane location of OTCase.

ATP-dependent metalloprotease FtsH (Cthe_2253, 66.6 kDa) was detected at over 880 kDa. FtsH is a cytoplasmic membrane-integrated protein that functions to processively degrade both cytoplasmic and membrane proteins in concert with protein unfolding and is known to form a large membrane-spanning holoenzyme of more than 1000 kDa with the prohibitin-like proteins HflK and HflC [43] or in a hexameric ring structure [44, 45]. Although HflK and HflC homologues were not detected from the gel, our results indicate that FtsH forms a large complex on the membrane.

Complexes in translation, ribosomal structure and biogenesis

Polyribonucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase, Cthe_0418, 77 kDa) was identified at ~150 kDa in the gel at a size of a dimer. It was reported to form a homo-trimer in eukaryotes, bacteria, and archaea [46–50] and was found in membrane fractions [51, 52].

Complexes in inorganic ion transport and metabolism

We detected ferritin (Cthe_0016, 18.6 kDa) at ~440 kDa, indicating that it is intact in a typical 24 mer form on BN-PAGE [53, 54]. But ferritin was also detected at over 110 kDa on SDS-PAGE, maybe due to incomplete denaturation. Ferritin is a well known membrane-bound protein.

Membrane Transport Complexes

Three solute binding proteins (BP, Cthe_1020, Cthe_1555, Cthe_1754), two ATP binding cassette proteins (ABC, Cthe_1557, Cthe_1862), one integral membrane component (IM, Cthe_1018), and an ABC transporter (Cthe_3148) with fused ABC and IM domains were identified from the SDS gel.

ABC transporter diverged into three main classes: Class 1 is comprised of fused ABC and IM domains; Class 2 is comprised of two tandem repeated ABC domains with no IM domains, this class likely does not function as transporters; Class 3 contains independent IM and ABC domains, that correspond to most BP-dependent importers[55]. A typical class 3 ABC transporter complex consists of one BP, two ABCs and two IMs, but the interactions of BP with the complex are weak, so most often only ABC and IM were isolated in a transporter complex [56, 57]. In Gram-positive bacteria, BP is either tethered to the cell surface via an N-terminal Cys residue covalently attached to the lipid membrane or by interaction with the IM component of a transporter complex [55].

An ABC transporter (Cthe_3148, 70 kDa) was detected at ~140 kDa, it is a Class 1 ABC transporter with fused ABC and IM domains. The estimated size of Cthe_3148 indicates that it was isolated in an intact dimeric form.

The solute binding protein (Cthe_1020, 49 kDa), the integral membrane protein (Cthe_1018, 32 kDa) and the ATP binding cassette protein (Cthe_1862, 42 kDa) were identified on a vertical line at ~190 kDa. In the genome of C. thermocellum, no ATP binding cassette proteins are found near Cthe_1020 and Cthe_1018, and Cthe_1862 is not adjacent to other BP or IM proteins. The identification of these proteins on a vertical line strongly suggests that they form a transporter complex. Cthe_1020 is an abundantly expressed protein under our culture condition, it was detected at ~100 kDa to over 880 kDa, and the high molecular weight spots maybe result of protein precipitation during electrophoresis.

Cthe_1555, Cthe_1556 and Cthe_1557 form an ABC transporter gene cluster in the genome. The ATP binding cassette protein (Cthe_1557, 30 kDa) was detected at an estimated molecular mass of ~140 kDa. But the integral membrane protein Cthe_1556 (26 kDa) and solute binding protein Cthe_1555 (32 kDa) were not detected. The estimated size of this ABC transporter complex suggests it contains two subunits of Cthe_1557, two subunits Cthe_1556 and one subunit of Cthe_1555 as an intact complex. Cthe_1555 was detected at ~100 kDa on a horizontal line with Cthe_1557, which could be due to dissociation of the transporter complex during electrophoresis.

Cthe_1752, Cthe_1753 and Cthe_1754 form an ABC transporter gene cluster in the genome. The solute binding protein (Cthe_1754, 36 kDa) was detected at ~170 kDa. But the integral membrane protein Cthe_1753 (37 kDa) and ATP binding cassette protein Cthe_1752 (30 kDa) was not detected. The size of ABC transporter complex estimated by BN-PAGE, suggests it contains two subunits Cthe_1752, two subunits Cthe_1753 and one subunit of Cthe_1754.

In this study, we did not detect the proteins in other ABC transporter gene clusters studied in vitro by Nataf [58] except Cthe_1020.

Other protein complexes

In Gram-positive bacteria, S-layer proteins are known to non-covalently attach to the pyruvylated negatively-charged secondary cell wall polymers (SCWP) by the surface layer homology (SLH) domains [59–61]. We detected S-layer protein (Cthe_2348, 113 kDa) at ~140 kDa, probably in a monomeric form, and there maybe a fragment of SCWP tethered with S-layer protein.

Prepilin (Cthe_1104, 19 kDa) was identified from 20 kDa to 180 kDa in the SDS gel, this may reflect that the prepilins were in a process of pilin assembly [62].

Hypothetical proteins

Three hypothetical proteins (Cthe_0858, Cthe_2693 and Cthe_2709) were detected in our membrane sample. Although Cthe_0858 showed weak similarity to domains designated PRK 13665, pfam 12127 and COG4864. The functions of these domains or their corresponding proteins are not known.

Bacterial strains and growth conditions

C. thermocellum DSM 1237 (ATCC 27405) was obtained from Deutsche Sammlung von Mikroorganismen und Zellkulturen. It was cultured at 60°C in a medium containing: (NH4)₂SO₄ 1.30 g, MgCl₂·6H₂O, 2.60 g, KH₂PO₄ 1.43 g, K₂HPO₄·3H₂O 7.20 g, CaCl₂·2H₂O 0.13 g, Na-β-glycerophosphate 6.00 g, FeSO₄·7H₂O 1.10 mg, Glutathione 0.25 g, Yeast Extract 4.50 g, Resazurin 1.00 mg, Cellobiose 5.00 g per litre water. The basal medium was adjusted to pH 7.2 with 10% NaOH and the headspace of the medium container was continuously flushed with oxygen-free nitrogen. All chemicals were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (St. Louis, MO, USA) unless otherwise noted.

Preparation of crude membrane protein fraction

C. thermocellum cells were harvested at late log phase by centrifugation at 8000 g for 10 min at 4°C, washed twice with 50 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.5), and then re-suspended in 50 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.5) containing 0.5 mM PMSF (Amresco). The re-suspended cells were disrupted by gentle sonication on ice (5 s pulse of sonication with 10 s intervals for 12 min) and centrifuged at 20,000 g for 30 min at 4°C. The pellet was discarded and the supernatant was centrifuged at 200,000 g for 60 min to obtain the membrane fraction. The membrane fraction was washed twice and finally re-suspended in solubilization buffer (50 mM NaCl, 50 mM Imidazole/HCl, 2 mM 6-Aminohexanoic acid (ACA), 1 mM EDTA, pH 7.0) and further treated for BN gel or stored at -80°C. Protein concentration was determined using the Bradford assay [65].

Protein complexes were solubilized at 4°C in solubilization buffer containing varying amounts of detergents. Triton X-100, DDM, Sulfobetaine SB10 and 3-[(3-cholamidopropyl) dimethylamonio]-1-propanesulfonate (Chaps) at concentrations ranging from 0.5% to 2.0% (w/v) were tested. Solubilization with 1.0% (w/v) DDM was found to be most effective, as evidenced by the number of complexes in the BN gel, the intensity and the molecular mass range of these complexes. Subsequent experiments were therefore performed using 1.0% (w/v) DDM as detergent. Following solubilization, samples were cleared by centrifugation at 200,000 g for 30 min at 4°C. The supernatant was mixed with 15 μl of G250 solution (5% (w/v) SERVA Blue G (SERVA Electrophoresis GmbH) in 500 mM ACA buffer) and loaded onto the BN gel.

Two dimensional BN/SDS PAGE

BN-PAGE and SDS-PAGE were performed using a DYY-23A apparatus (product of Beijing WoDeLife Sciences Instrument Company). In the first dimensional BN-PAGE, approximately 40 μg of protein was loaded. A 3.5% stacking and a 4-15% separating gel (gel dimensions 10 cm×10 cm×1.5 mm) were used. Buffers and gel compositions used were the same as described by Wittig et al [66]. Electrophoresis was conducted at 100 V for 30 min, and following electrophoresis was performed with the current limited to 15 mA and voltage limited to 300 V. Ferritin, catalase and BSA from Amersham Biosciences (Sweden) were used as markers to indicate the sizes of 880, 440, 250, 132 and 66 kDa. BN-polyacrylamide gel strips were cut from the first dementional gel for use in the second dimensional SDS-PAGE.

For the second dimensional SDS-PAGE, strips of the first dimensional BN-PAGE were cut and soaked in 5% (w/v) SDS, 1% (w/v) 2-Mercaptoethanol for 2 h. SDS-PAGEs were performed using a 4% stacking and a 12% separating gel according to standard protocols. Gels were fixed in 50% (v/v) methanol and 12% (v/v) acetic acid for 1 hour and then stained with 0.25% (w/v) Coomassie Blue R250 in 10% (v/v) acetic acid and 50% (v/v) methanol. A series of proteins (Tiangen Company, China) with the sizes of 116, 66.2, 45, 35, 25, 18.4 and 14.4 kDa were used as markers.

MALDI-TOF MS and MS/MS

Protein spots from SDS gel were excised manually. In-gel trypsin digestion was carried out as previously described [67]. A 0.4 μl aliquot of the concentrated tryptic peptide mixture in 0.1% trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) was mixed with 0.4 μl of α-cyano-4-hydroxycinnamic acid (CHCA) matrix solution (5 mg/ml CHCA in 50% ACN/0.1% TFA) and spotted onto a freshly cleaned target plate. After air drying, the crystallized spots were analyzed on the Applied Biosystems 4700 Proteomics Analyzer MALDI-TOF/TOF (Applied Biosystems, Framingham, MA, USA). MS calibration was automatically performed by a peptide standard Kit (Applied Biosystems) containing des-Arg1-bradykinin (m/z 904), Angiotensin I (m/z 1296.6851), Glu1-fibrinopeptide B (m/z 1570.6774), Adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) (1-17, m/z 2903.0867), ACTH (18-39, m/z 2465.1989), and ACTH (7-38, m/z 3657.9294) and MS/MS calibration was performed by the MS/MS fragment peaks of Glu1-fibrinopeptide B. All MS mass spectra were recorded in the reflector positive mode using a laser operated at a 200 Hz repetition rate with wavelength of 355 nm. The accelerated voltage was operated at 2 kV. The MS/MS mass spectra were acquired by the data dependent acquisition method with the 10 strongest precursors selected from one MS scan. All MS and MS/MS spectra were obtained by accumulation of at least 1000 and 3000 laser shots, respectively. Neither baseline subtraction nor smoothing was applied to recorded spectra. MS and MS/MS data were analyzed and peak lists were generated using GPS Explorer 3.5 (Applied Biosystems). MS peaks were selected between 700 and 3500 Da and filtered with a signal to noise ratio greater than 20. A peak intensity filter was used with no more than 50 peaks per 200 Da. MS/MS peaks were selected based on a signal to noise ratio greater than 10 over a mass range of 60 Da to 20 Da below the precursor mass. MS and MS/MS data were analyzed using MASCOT™ 2.0 search engine (Matrix Science, London, UK) to search against the C. themocellum protein sequence database downloaded from NCBI database on December 01 2008. Searching parameters were as follows: trypsin digestion with one missed cleavage, variable modifications (oxidation of methionine and carbamidomethylation of cysteine), and the mass tolerance of precursor ion and fragment ion at 0.2 Da for +1 charged ions. For all proteins successfully identified by Peptide Mass Fingerprint and/or MS/MS, Mascot score greater than 53 (the default MASCOT threshold for such searches) was accepted as significant (p value < 0.05). The false positive rate was estimated based on reverse database search. The false positive rate = peptide fragment numbers detected in reverse database search/(peptide fragment numbers in forward database search+ peptide fragment numbers in reverse database search) × 100%.