- Research article
- Open Access
Examining the relationship between maternal body size, gestational glucose tolerance status, mode of delivery and ethnicity on human milk microbiota at three months post-partum
BMC Microbiology volume 20, Article number: 219 (2020)
Few studies have examined how maternal body mass index (BMI), mode of delivery and ethnicity affect the microbial composition of human milk and none have examined associations with maternal metabolic status. Given the high prevalence of maternal adiposity and impaired glucose metabolism, we systematically investigated the associations between these maternal factors in women ≥20 years and milk microbial composition and predicted functionality by V4-16S ribosomal RNA gene sequencing (NCT01405547; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT01405547). Demographic data, weight, height, and a 3-h oral glucose tolerance test were gathered at 30 (95% CI: 25–33) weeks gestation, and milk samples were collected at 3 months post-partum (n = 113).
Multivariable linear regression analyses demonstrated no significant associations between maternal characteristics (maternal BMI [pre-pregnancy, 3 months post-partum], glucose tolerance, mode of delivery and ethnicity) and milk microbiota alpha-diversity; however, pre-pregnancy BMI was associated with human milk microbiota beta-diversity (Bray-Curtis R2 = 0.037). Women with a pre-pregnancy BMI > 30 kg/m2 (obese) had a greater incidence of Bacteroidetes (incidence rate ratio [IRR]: 3.70 [95% CI: 1.61–8.48]) and a reduced incidence of Proteobacteria (0.62 [0.43–0.90]) in their milk, compared to women with an overweight BMI (25.0–29.9 kg/m2) as assessed by multivariable Poisson regression. An increased incidence of Gemella was observed among mothers with gestational diabetes who had an overweight BMI versus healthy range BMI (5.96 [1.85–19.21]). An increased incidence of Gemella was also observed among mothers with impaired glucose tolerance with an obese BMI versus mothers with a healthy range BMI (4.04 [1.63–10.01]). An increased incidence of Brevundimonas (16.70 [5.99–46.57]) was found in the milk of women who underwent an unscheduled C-section versus vaginal delivery. Lastly, functional gene inference demonstrated that pre-pregnancy obesity was associated with an increased abundance of genes encoding for the biosynthesis of secondary metabolites pathway in milk (coefficient = 0.0024, PFDR < 0.1).
Human milk has a diverse microbiota of which its diversity and differential abundance appear associated with maternal BMI, glucose tolerance status, mode of delivery, and ethnicity. Further research is warranted to determine whether this variability in the milk microbiota impacts colonization of the infant gut.
Breastfeeding is the recommended method of feeding for all infants irrespective of whether the country of origin is low, middle, or high-income . Human milk is a rich source of nutrients and bioactive components, such as the antimicrobial proteins lactoferrin and lysozyme, and contains an array of oligosaccharides which serve as a source of prebiotics [2,3,4,5]. It is now well accepted that human milk contains a rich supply of bacteria (~ 106 bacterial cells/mL), which are believed to play an important role in postnatal colonization of the infant’s gastrointestinal tract (gut) [6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13]. Microbial composition of the gut, in turn, is associated with maturation of an infant’s gut and immune system, and aberrant gut microbial compositions have been linked to a number of short- and long-term health outcomes including diarrhea, respiratory tract infection, asthma, inflammatory bowel disease, obesity, and metabolic syndrome [14,15,16,17,18].
There is a limited understanding of the stability of the human milk microbiota in the face of environmental influences. Despite the high prevalence and known impact on other milk constituents, no study we are aware of has examined the association between maternal glucose tolerance status, either gestational diabetes or impaired glucose tolerance, and the milk microbiota. Only a few studies to date have cross-sectionally examined other maternal factors, such as maternal BMI and mode of delivery, on the microbiota composition of mature human milk (collected from 1-week to 6-months post-partum) [19,20,21,22,23]. Moreover, the findings from the few available studies are inconsistent likely due, in part, to the small number of study participants, and differing methods of milk collection and analysis (Additional file 1, Table S1). Of the limited studies conducted, maternal BMI and mode of delivery have been associated with the mature milk microbiota; however, many of these reports relied on small cohorts and thus their findings require replication in larger studies [19,20,21,22,23]. Further, most studies were unable to employ multivariable statistical modelling to adjust for multiple potential maternal factors of interest simultaneously. Lastly, none of these studies carried out functional inference analyses to determine if maternal BMI and mode of delivery also perturb the milk microbiome’s potential metabolic activities or predicted functional capabilities.
Therefore, we set out to fill these knowledge gaps in the field by taking advantage of milk samples and clinical metadata that had been previously collected from women enrolled in a prospective cohort study to investigate the impact of metabolic abnormalities and maternal nutrition in pregnancy on human milk composition (NCT01405547). The objective of this current study was to investigate the associations between maternal pre-pregnancy BMI (healthy, overweight, or obese), 3-month post-partum BMI, maternal glucose tolerance status in late pregnancy (gestational diabetes mellitus [GDM], impaired glucose tolerance [IGT], or normoglycemia), mode of delivery (vaginal delivery, unscheduled Caesarean delivery [C-section], or scheduled C-section), and ethnicity (white, Asian, or other [South Asian, Black, other]) on the microbial community composition and predicted functional capabilities of human milk at 3 months post-partum. This research will help to elucidate the modulatory potential of human milk microbiota in the face of physiological perturbations.
Milk samples were collected at 3 ± 1-month post-partum (mean ± standard deviation [SD]) (n = 113). Fifty-six (49.6%) mothers fed their infants their own milk exclusively at the time of milk collection (versus 57 [50.4%] mixed feeds), and 61 (53.9%) samples were from a complete breast expression (versus 52 [46.0%] from incomplete breast expression). The mean (± SD) age of the mothers was 34.2 ± 4.2 years (Table 1) with a pre-pregnancy BMI (kg/m2) of 24.3 ± 4.6, which is within a healthy BMI range (18.5–24.9 kg/m2). A modified oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT) administered at 30 weeks’ gestation (95% CI: 25–33 weeks) revealed that 24 (21.2%) women had GDM, 20 (17.7%) had IGT, and 69 (61.1%) had healthy glucose metabolism (normoglycemic). Among women with a healthy pre-pregnancy BMI, 12 and 16 had IGT and GDM, respectively. Among women with an overweight pre-pregnancy BMI, 5 had IGT and 5 had GDM (10 total). Lastly, among women with an obese pre-pregnancy BMI 3 had IGT and 3 had GDM (6 total; Additional file 2, Table S2). Sixty-four (56.6%) mothers delivered their infants vaginally, compared to the 49 (43.4%) who underwent a C-section.
Overall microbial composition of human milk
Following V4-16S rRNA gene sequencing, the average sequencing depth was found to be 63,025 (SD, 41,068) reads per sample. Data were rarefied to 20,000 reads per sample prior to calculating diversity metrics, and 4 samples were removed from analyses due to low sequence counts following filtering and rarefying (n = 109). Twenty-six unique phyla-level and 292 unique genus-level taxa were identified (Figs. 1 and 2). Proteobacteria and Firmicutes were the most abundant phyla at 58.6 ± 27.3% and 35.6 ± 26.3%, respectively, followed by Actinobacteria (4.1 ± 4.7%), Bacteroidetes (1.4 ± 2.7%), and Fusobacteria (0.1 ± 0.3%). Pseudomonas (43.4 ± 26.0%) and Streptococcus (30.6 ± 25.3%) were the predominant genera across all samples, followed by smaller abundances of Staphylococcus (6.2 ± 11.5%), Acinetobacter (3.5 ± 7.4%), Veillonella (3.2 ± 7.2%), Gemella (1.9 ± 3.3%), Corynebacterium (1.6 ± 5.5%), Rothia (1.3 ± 2.4%), Aeromonas (0.6 ± 6.2%), and Brevundimonas (0.6 ± 5.7%). Plotting the relative abundances of taxa at the phylum (Fig. 1) and genus (Fig. 2) taxonomic levels revealed obvious inter-individual variability in the microbial composition of milk. Of the top 5 phyla and top 10 genera, all taxa, with the exception of Fusobacteria and Aeromonas, were found in > 96% of all milk samples (Additional file 3, Table S3).
Associations between maternal BMI, glucose tolerance status, mode of delivery, ethnicity and the milk microbiota
The Chao1 and Shannon indices were used to assess alpha-diversity (richness and diversity, respectively) within each human milk sample. No statistically significant associations were found between maternal characteristics (maternal glucose tolerance status, mode of delivery, pre-pregnancy BMI, 3-month post-partum BMI, ethnicity), and milk microbiota richness or diversity using multivariable linear regression analyses (Fig. 3a-e; results in Additional file 4, Table S4).
To further investigate associations between maternal characteristics and microbial composition, beta-diversity of the milk microbiota was assessed by principal coordinate analysis (PCoA) using the weighted UniFrac distance metric and the Bray-Curtis index of dissimilarity (Additional file 5, Fig. S1A-E; Additional file 6, Fig. S2A-E; Additional file 7, Table S5) . No obvious clustering or separation based on maternal characteristics was observed; however, a small but statistically significant association between maternal pre-pregnancy BMI and beta-diversity clustering was identified (Bray-Curtis R2 = 0.037, p = 0.031). No other statistically significant associations were found for the other maternal characteristics and beta-diversity.
We assessed whether taxa abundance was associated with maternal characteristics by using multivariable Poisson regression models and accounting for multiple comparisons (Table 2; Additional file 8, Table S6; Additional file 9, Table S7; Additional file 10, Table S8; Additional file 11, Table S9). At least one maternal characteristic was associated with the differential abundance of Proteobacteria, Bacteroidetes, Firmicutes and Actinobacteria at the phylum level, and Staphylococcus, Streptococcus, Pseudomonas, Veillonella, Gemella, Aeromonas, Corynebacterium and Brevundimonas at the genus level.
Association between maternal BMI and the milk microbiota
Pre-pregnancy BMI (i.e., healthy, overweight, obese) was found to be most consistently associated with differentially abundant taxa after controlling for relevant maternal characteristics. Mothers categorized as obese pre-pregnancy displayed a lower incidence of Proteobacteria (incidence rate ratio [IRR]: 0.62 [95% CI: 0.43–0.90]) in their milk as compared to mothers with an overweight BMI (Table 2). Conversely, mothers with overweight presented with an increased incidence of Proteobacteria in their milk, compared to healthy weight mothers (1.23 [1.00–1.50]). Mothers defined as obese pre-pregnancy had a greater incidence of Bacteroidetes in their milk as compared to mothers with an overweight (3.70 [1.61–8.48]) or healthy BMI (2.56 [1.27–5.17]). When examining 3-month post-partum BMI, Actinobacteria incidence was greater in women with obesity versus both mothers with an overweight (2.34 [1.38–3.98]) or healthy BMI (2.02 [1.18–3.46]).
At the genus-level, women with obesity pre-pregnancy displayed a higher incidence of Staphylococcus as compared to mothers with an overweight (2.50 [1.09–5.72]) or healthy BMI (3.15 [1.47–6.08]) (Table 2). Mothers with an obese BMI pre-pregnancy also displayed a greater incidence of Corynebacterium in their milk versus both mothers with an overweight (5.13 [1.79–14.70]) or healthy BMI (4.98 [2.11–11.74]). This same relationship with Corynebacterium was seen in mothers with obesity at 3-months post-partum compared to mothers with overweight (4.84 [2.19–10.72]) or a healthy BMI (7.77 [2.95–20.43]). An increased incidence of Brevundimonas was also observed in mothers with an overweight BMI pre-pregnancy versus healthy BMI (8.72 [3.24–23.48]). At 3-months post-partum, women with obesity also displayed a greater incidence of Brevundimonas versus both those with overweight (8.89 [2.29–34.57]) and those at a healthy weight (9.56 [2.17–42.22]) (Table 2).
Association between maternal glucose tolerance status and the milk microbiota
When examining the interaction between BMI and maternal glucose tolerance status, Gemella showed an increased incidence among mothers with an overweight (versus healthy) BMI with gestational diabetes (5.96 [1.85–19.21]) (Additional file 11, Table S9). In addition, Gemella was increased in mother’s with obesity and concurrent impaired glucose tolerance versus both overweight (11.42 [1.49–87.67]) and healthy BMI (4.04 [1.63–10.01]) mothers with impaired glucose tolerance.
Association between mode of delivery and the milk microbiota
Associations between mode of delivery and the differential abundance of select taxa at the phylum and genus level were found for both pre-pregnancy and post-partum BMI models (Table 2, Additional file 11, Table S9). A greater incidence of Brevundimonas was observed in mothers who underwent an unscheduled C-section versus a vaginal delivery from both the pre-pregnancy BMI model (16.70 [5.99–46.57]) and 3-month post-partum BMI model (13.01 [4.01–42.20]). Conversely, a reduced incidence of Brevundimonas was observed in mothers who underwent a scheduled C-section versus an unscheduled C-section in both the pre-pregnancy BMI model (0.071 [0.011–0.46]) and the 3-month post-partum BMI model (0.08 [0.013–0.62]).
Association between maternal ethnicity and the milk microbiota
Lastly, ethnicity (white, Asian, other [South Asian, Black, other]) was associated with the differential abundance of Corynebacterium, Brevundimonas and Aeromonas (Table 3). White mothers had a reduced incidence of both Corynebacterium (0.27 [0.12–0.59]) and Brevundimonas (0.084 [0.015–0.46]) when compared to ‘other’ mothers and Asian mothers, respectively; Asian mothers also had a reduced incidence of Corynebacterium when compared to ‘other’ mothers (0.17 [0.049–0.63]).
Association between maternal BMI, glucose tolerance status, mode of delivery, ethnicity and functional gene expression of the milk microbiota
We carried out functional inference analyses using Piphillin to assess if there were any differences in predicted functional capabilities of the milk microbiota based on the maternal clinical data. In contrast with the bacterial taxonomic results, the relative abundance of the 20 top KEGG pathways across all milk samples was fairly consistent (Additional file 12, Fig. S3). We analyzed the association between maternal clinical data and KEGG ortholog (KO) beta-diversity as well as examined the association between maternal clinical parameters and differentially-expressed KEGG pathways (Additional file 13, Table S10; Additional file 14, Table S11; Additional file 15, Table S12). No significant associations were found when examining metadata and KO beta-diversity (Additional file 13, Table S10); however, one statistically significant differentially-expressed set of pathways was observed (Additional file 14, Table S11; Additional file 16, Fig. S4). BMI, specifically the obese sub-category, was shown to be associated with enrichment of the KEGG pathway “Biosynthesis of secondary metabolites” (coefficient = 0.0024, PFDR < 0.1) (Additional file 16, Fig. S4). Analysis of individual genes within this KEGG pathway and maternal metadata did not yield any statistically significant associations.
Our results suggest that maternal factors, and most consistently maternal pre-pregnancy BMI, are associated with the microbial composition of human milk. This is the first study to include maternal glucose tolerance status in the investigations of the association between maternal BMI and the milk microbiota (Additional file 1, Table S1). Gestational diabetes is associated with a number of negative health outcomes, including an increased risk of type 2 diabetes and metabolic syndrome in the mother. According to a recent systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis, the risk of GDM increases by 4% for every unit increase in BMI . While some negative health outcomes associated with GDM are related to maternal adiposity and vice versa, others are thought to be independently related to chronically impaired glucose metabolism. Thus, it is important to investigate the impact of maternal BMI and GDM together on the composition of the milk microbiota. Our results show a significant interaction between pre-pregnancy BMI and gestational glucose intolerance on the differential abundance of Gemella in human milk. This suggests that associations between pre-pregnancy maternal BMI and the human milk microbiota are differentially impacted by maternal glucose tolerance status.
We did not find any differences in alpha-diversity based on our maternal characteristics; however, we did find statistically significant differences in beta-diversity, with human milk microbiota separating, or non-randomly clustering, based on pre-pregnancy BMI even after adjustment for other covariates (Additional file 5, Fig. S1; Additional file 6, Fig. S1; Additional file 7, Table S5). The human gut microbiota has been reported to cluster as a function of body size, but this has not yet been reported for the human milk microbiota . Our results demonstrating an association between maternal BMI and microbial composition is consistent with other smaller scale studies on human milk microbiotas (Additional file 1, Table S1). Cabrera-Rubio et al. (2012) examined the association between maternal body size and the differential abundance of human milk genera in a study of healthy Finnish women (n = 18) . They reported an increase in Staphylococcus in human milk collected from obese women, which mirrors the findings in our study (Additional file 8, Table S6).
Mode of delivery was also associated with changes in the human milk microbiota at both the phylum and genus levels (Table 2; Additional file 8, Table S6). For example, we observed greater differential abundance of Staphylococcus in human milk from women who underwent a scheduled C-section versus vaginal delivery (Additional file 8, Table S6). Our results are similar to that reported by Cabrera-Rubio et al. (2012, 2016). These two small cross-sectional cohorts of healthy Finnish women (n = 18, 10) showed a non-statistically significant increase in Staphylococcus in milk observed among women who delivered their infant via a scheduled C-section versus a vaginal delivery [19, 20]. The proposed mechanism whereby mode of delivery alters the milk microbiota is via the infant oral cavity, which is colonized during either vaginal delivery or C-section; from here, retrograde inoculation of bacteria can occur from the infant’s oral cavity into the mammary gland via the suckling process with direct breastfeeding [9, 27,28,29]. Understanding how an infant’s gut microbiota and overall health is impacted by differences in the milk microbiota based on mode of delivery remains uninvestigated. Future studies profiling the human milk microbiome, infant salivary microbiome and gut microbiome with repeated clinical follow-up over time would help answer these questions.
The results of our multi-ethnic cohort revealed associations between ethnicity and specific bacterial taxa. Ethnicity and/or geographic location have been shown to be factors in determining various microbiomes of the body including the gut, oral cavity, respiratory tract, skin, and urogenital tract . Ethnicity and geographic location typically come with an overlay of dietary variation, making the impact of each variable challenging to separate. Only a few studies to date have assessed associations between ethnicity and the milk microbiota; however, the ethnic/geographic groups differed from our study as they generally examined Europe, Africa and the United States, making it challenging to compare findings (Table 3; Additional file 9, Table S7; Additional file 11, Table S9) [12, 21, 31, 32].
We used a functional inference approach to characterize the microbial genetic potential in human milk. In agreement with what has been reported for other human-associated microbiotas, the functional capacity of the human milk microbiota is more stable than its taxonomic composition . We then assessed whether there were specific predicted pathways that were suggested to be associated with maternal characteristics and found that maternal pre-pregnancy BMI, specifically the obese sub-category, was significantly associated with an increase in the “Biosynthesis of secondary metabolites” predicted KEGG pathway. Microbes produce secondary metabolites, which are small, bioactive molecules, not necessary for growth or development but are instead involved in microbe-host or microbe-microbe interactions [34, 35]. Indeed, many of the genes in the biosynthesis of secondary metabolites pathway encode for the biosynthesis of antibiotics . We assessed whether any individual genes (KO terms) involved in the predicted “Biosynthesis of secondary metabolites” pathway were significantly associated with BMI using MaAsLin2; however, no statistically significant associations were found. We hypothesize this may mean it is the culmination of many genes together that are leading to the enrichment of the “Biosynthesis of secondary metabolites” pathway, and not one individual gene. However, these observations require confirmation in future studies.
Human milk is considered a low biomass sample and, for this reason, may be more affected by sample processing than higher biomass samples, such as stool. To address this concern, we used PCoA plots to visualize clustering, or lack thereof, of our milk samples and negative controls (Additional file 17, Fig. S5). Our negative controls were seen to cluster away from the samples, suggesting that our results do not arise from technical contaminates, which was confirmed using Adonis analyses to statistically corroborate that our samples clustered away from the negative controls (Weighted UniFrac R2 = 0.07, p = 0.0001; Bray-Curtis R2 = 0.10, p = 0.0001, Additional file 17, Fig. S5).
Strengths of the current study include the varied ethnicity of women included, clinical examination via an OGTT, and enrichment of the cohort with women of varying body sizes who had abnormal glucose tolerance status. These strengths allowed for a more fulsome investigation using multivariable statistics to determine how each maternal factor is independently associated with the milk microbiome. Despite our larger sample size as compared to most earlier studies, we did not have sufficient sample size for adjustment of all covariates of interest (e.g., maternal diet) and thus were not able to perform the granular analyses needed to fully investigate the sub-groups within each metadata category. Future research should strive for larger sample sizes providing greater statistical power in order to capture more potential confounders. Additionally, although an acceptable sequencing depth was reached, rare but important microbes may still have been missed as our methods may not have been sensitive enough to pick up on certain important microbes. The compositional nature of data generated from next-generation sequencing also remains a challenge since it is limited to assessing relative (versus absolute) abundance; in other words, it holds the assumption that if one bacterial taxa increases, another bacterial taxa must conversely decrease, regardless of how the absolute abundance of these taxa may be changing [37,38,39]. Lastly, although interesting, the use of Piphillin to determine associations between metadata and predicted pathways is only hypothesis generating and requires confirmation using a combination of shotgun metagenomics, metabolomic profiling or comparison of matched human milk samples. Moreover, the microbes identified in the milk from the present study likely include bacteria from the mother’s skin microbiota as her breast was not disinfected prior to milk sampling. Practically, however, mothers do not disinfect their breast prior to pumping and storing milk for their infant, nor do they disinfect prior to breastfeeding. Therefore, the human milk microbiota as collected in the current study is likely a more accurate depiction of what the infant would receive. Finally, our study is limited by its cross-sectional analytic design and thus we cannot assess how the milk microbiota changes over time. It is possible that the associations we identified between maternal factors and microbial composition in milk are not transitory and change across the course of lactation.
Our study found that human milk has a highly personalized microbiota with high inter-individual variability. Expressed human milk at both the phylum and genus levels appear to be related to maternal metabolic and obstetrical factors. Surprisingly, glucose tolerance status was significantly associated with fewer microbiota parameters than anticipated. Most consistently, maternal pre-pregnancy BMI, despite glucose tolerance status, was associated with the differential abundance of various taxa in human milk and potentially the production of bacterial secondary metabolites as well. To understand the clinical significance of these findings, future research should explore how differences in the microbial composition of human milk impact infant’s microbial colonization and overall health.
Study participants and design
To address the research objectives of this study, we used maternal metabolic and obstetrical health data along with bio-banked human milk samples available from a previously conducted prospective cohort study (ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT01405547); a detailed description of the study protocol has been previously published . Pregnant women (n = 216) were recruited from outpatient clinics at Mount Sinai Hospital in Toronto, Canada and completed a 3-h 100 g OGTT between March 2009 and July 2010. In total, 117 women donated a milk sample at 3 months post-partum, with 113 samples available for this study (Additional file 18, Fig. S6). Women were eligible for inclusion in the original study if they were ≥ 20 years of age and had an intention to breastfeed. Exclusion criteria included pre-existing diabetes diagnosis, current use of insulin, or completion of an OGTT prior to recruitment . By design, mothers were recruited from clinics which follow higher risk pregnancies with a greater risk of either GDM or IGT diagnosis.
Collection of demographic, anthropometric and metabolic data
During the first study visit, which occurred in late pregnancy (30 weeks [95% CI: 25–33 weeks]), demographic and anthropometric data were collected (e.g. age, ethnicity, weight, height); mothers were asked to recall their pre-pregnancy weight. All pregnant women in Canada are screened for GDM by way of a 50 g glucose challenge test (GCT). If the plasma glucose concentration at 1-h post-glucose load is ≥7.8 mmol/L, the patient is then referred for a diagnostic OGTT. Contrary to standard obstetrical practice, all women completed a 3-h 100 g OGTT in the current study during their first study visit regardless of whether or not they completed a GCT. The OGTT involved having blood samples drawn at fasting, 30, 60, 90, 120- and 180-min post-glucose load. Women were then diagnosed with either GDM, IGT, or as normoglycemic based on the following glycemic thresholds: 1) GDM diagnosis = 2 or more of the following: fasting blood glucose ≥5.8 mmol/L, 1-h blood glucose ≥10.6 mmol/L, 2-h blood glucose ≥9.2 mmol/L, or 3-h blood glucose ≥8.1 mmol/L, or 2) IGT diagnosis would exceed only one of the previous thresholds, or 3) normoglycemic = normal OGTT .
Human milk collection, processing and amplification
At the three-month post-partum research visit, mothers were asked to pump a complete breast expression of milk using a double electric breast pump (Medela Inc., Illinois, USA) with a sterile pumping kit. Mothers were instructed not to pump or breastfeed their infant for 2 h before the study visit. Samples of whole human milk were then divided into aliquots and stored at − 80 °C until the time of analyses.
DNA was extracted from human milk using the NucleoSpin Food DNA Isolation Kit (Macherey-Nagel, Pennsylvania, USA) according to manufacturer’s instructions with modifications as we have described previously . Due to the small concentration of DNA in human milk, an elution buffer volume of 30 μL, instead of the recommended 100 μL, was used to ensure adequate DNA concentrations for downstream PCR.
PCR amplification of the V4 hypervariable region was performed using the forward primer (515F) 5’AATGATACGGCGACCACCGAGATCTACACTATGGTA ATTGTGTGCCAGCMGCCGCGGTAA and reverse primer (806R) 5’CAAGCAGA AGACGGCATACGAGATA GTCAGTCAGCCGGACTACHVGGGTWTCTAAT . PCR reactions were set up following the manufacturer’s recommendations (Roche) including 12.5 μL of KAPA2G Robust HotStart ReadyMix, 1.5 μL of 10 μM forward and 1.5 μL of 10 μM reverse primer, 3.5 μL of sterile water and 6 μL of DNA. Amplification of the V4 hypervariable region of the 16S rRNA gene involved 28 cycles of PCR: 95 °C for 3 min, 25–30 cycles of 95 °C for 15 s, 50 °C for 15 s and 72 °C for 15 s, followed by a 5 min 72 °C extension (different numbers of cycles between PCR runs were adjusted for statistically). All amplifications were completed in triplicate and all amplicons were run on a 1% TBE agarose gel to ensure accurate amplification (amplicon size ~ 390 bp). A negative control without template DNA and a positive control with DNA from a known bacterial species (Pseudomonas aeruginosa) were also included to confirm the amplification quality. Bands of the same size and intensity were pooled and quantified to create the pooled sequence library. Purification of the pooled library was completed with AMPure XP beads (0.8X volume of beads to 1X volume of library DNA) following the manufacturer’s protocol. The purified library was quantified using the Qubit High Sensitivity DNA Kit (Thermo Fisher Scientific). The quantified library was loaded on an Illumina MiSeq and sequenced using the MiSeq-V2–300 cycle chemistry to generate 150 PE reads.
The raw paired end sequences from the MiSeq instrument have been deposited to the NCBI Sequence Read Archive (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sra) under accession number PRJNA516669. The UPARSE pipeline (USEARCH) was used for sequence analysis. Raw paired end sequences were assembled (−fastq_mergepairs; −fastq_merge_maxee =1.0), filtered (−fastq_filter; −fastq_maxee = 0.5) and sequences shorter than 225 base pairs were removed (−fastq_filter; −fastq_minlen 225) . Sequences were then de-replicated and sorted using USEARCH (−derep_full; −sortybysize). Chimeric sequences in the OTUs were detected and removed using the Ribosomal Database Project (RDP) 16S gold database (USEARCH), while ensuring the number of false positive chimeras detected was minimized . Sequences were then grouped together into Operational Taxonomic Units (OTUs) at 97% similarity (−usearch_global). Taxonomy was assigned to these OTUs (RDP 16S gold database) (−utax) and OTU fasta sequences were aligned using PyNast via a QIIME python script (align_seqs.py). A phylogenetic tree was assembled using the FastTree QIIME python script (make_phylogeny.py) .
Data analysis and statistics
The phyloseq package (1.25.2) in R (version 3.4.1) was used to analyze microbiota composition . OTUs that only appeared once or twice (singletons and doubletons) were removed and all OTUs were rarefied to 20,000 reads/sample prior to calculating relative abundances at different taxonomic levels, alpha-diversity and beta-diversity using phyloseq.
Statistically significant differences between the alpha diversities (Chao1/Shannon indices determined in R) and maternal metabolic or obstetrical characteristics were determined using multivariable linear regression models (PROC MIXED) in SAS version 9.4. Independent variables included in the models were: maternal BMI (healthy = 18.5–24.9 kg/m2, overweight = 25–29.9 kg/m2, obese= > 30 kg/m2), maternal glucose tolerance status (GDM, IGT, normoglycemic), mode of delivery (vaginal, unscheduled C-section, scheduled C-section), DNA extraction batch, and PCR sequencing batch. Separate statistical models were built using pre-pregnancy and 3-month post-partum BMI as covariates, due to concerns about collinearity. An interaction term between BMI and maternal glucose tolerance status was also tested in each model and removed if it was non-significant. Due to our sample size and the number of covariates we wished to test, separate models for ethnicity (white, Asian, other [South Asian, Black, other]) were run that adjusted for DNA extraction and PCR sequencing batches, but no other covariates. Multicollinearity was assessed between independent variables in all models, using a variance inflation cut-off of > 5. The significance level was set at p < 0.05. Of note, 6 mothers with a pre-pregnancy BMI between 18.0–18.4 kg/m2 were placed in the “healthy BMI” group for all analyses.
Beta diversities and principal coordinate analysis (PCoA) were also ascertained in phyloseq and statistical significance based on maternal characteristics was determined using the adonis function in vegan (version 2.5–3) . Adonis assesses the amount of variation explained by each metadata variable, such as maternal BMI or glucose tolerance status; all variables were run individually and together in adonis to adjust for one another. The interaction term between BMI and glucose tolerance status was also tested and removed if non-significant. Four patient samples were missing the post-partum BMI data and thus we used their pre-pregnancy BMI for the post-partum analyses. Again, the significance level was set at p < 0.05.
Multivariable Poisson regression models (PROC GENMOD) were run in SAS version 9.4 to assess differential abundance at the phylum and genus levels based on maternal characteristics. The Benjamini-Yekutieli cut point approach was used to account for multiple testing. A p ≤ 0.022 at the phylum level (5 tests) and p ≤ 0.017 (10 tests) at the genus level were considered statistically significant for the overall group effect. If the overall group-adjusted p-value was significant, pairwise comparisons were conducted and a pairwise p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Piphillin: functional analysis of human milk microbiota
Piphillin, a metagenomics inference tool, was used to infer functional capabilities in milk samples (https://piphillin.secondgenome.com/) . In this study, the Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG; https://www.genome.jp/kegg/) was used as a reference database to retrieve gene copy numbers and create a gene feature table from the 16S rRNA sequence data. Statistically significant associations between maternal characteristics and KEGG pathways were assessed in three ways: 1) examining the association between maternal characteristics and KO beta-diversity using Adonis in R (p < 0.05), 2) investigating metadata associated with differentially-expressed predicted functional pathways using MaAsLin2 in R (PFDR < 0.1) and 3) investigating metadata associated with individual genes (KO) found in the differentially expressed functional pathways from step 2.
Availability of data and materials
The sequences can be accessed at NCBI Sequence Read Archive (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sra) with accession number PRJNA516669. Patient clinical data are not publicly available to protect patient anonymity and confidentiality.
Body mass index
- C-section :
Gestational diabetes mellitus
Impaired glucose tolerance
Incidence rate ratio
Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes
Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) ortholog
Oral glucose tolerance test
Operational taxonomic unit
Principal coordinates analysis
Victora CG, Bahl R, Barros AJD, França GVA, Horton S, Krasevec J, et al. Breastfeeding in the 21st century: epidemiology, mechanisms, and lifelong effect. Lancet. 2016;387(10017):475–90.
Bode L. Human milk oligosaccharides: every baby needs a sugar mama. Glycobiology. 2012;22(9):1147–62.
Riskin A, Almog M, Peri R, Halasz K, Srugo I, Kessel A. Changes in immunomodulatory constituents of human milk in response to active infection in the nursing infant. Pediatr Res. 2012;71(2):220–5.
Wagner CL, Taylor SN, Johnson D. Host factors in amniotic fluid and breast milk that contribute to gut maturation. Clin Rev Allergy Immunol. 2008;34(2):191–204.
Sabbaj S, Ibegbu CC, Kourtis AP. Cellular immunity in breast milk: implications for postnatal transmission of HIV-1 to the infant. Adv Exp Med Biol. 2012;743:161–9.
Arrieta M-C, Stiemsma LT, Amenyogbe N, Brown EM, Finlay B. The intestinal microbiome in early life: health and disease. Front Immunol. 2014;5:427.
Azad MB, Konya T, Maughan H, Guttman DS, Field CJ, Chari RS, et al. Gut microbiota of healthy Canadian infants: profiles by mode of delivery and infant diet at 4 months. CMAJ. 2013;185(5):385–94.
Boix-Amorós A, Collado MC, Mira A. Relationship between milk microbiota, bacterial load, macronutrients, and human cells during lactation. Front Microbiol. 2016;7:492.
Fernández L, Langa S, Martín V, Maldonado A, Jiménez E, Martín R, et al. The human milk microbiota: origin and potential roles in health and disease. Pharmacol Res. 2013;69(1):1–10.
Jost T, Lacroix C, Braegger CP, Rochat F, Chassard C. Vertical mother-neonate transfer of maternal gut bacteria via breastfeeding. Environ Microbiol. 2014;16(9):2891–904.
Murphy K, Curley D, O’Callaghan TF, O’Shea C-A, Dempsey EM, O’Toole PW, et al. The composition of human milk and infant faecal microbiota over the first three months of life: a pilot study. Sci Rep. 2017;7:40597.
Pannaraj PS, Li F, Cerini C, Bender JM, Yang S, Rollie A, et al. Association between breast milk bacterial communities and establishment and development of the infant gut microbiome. JAMA Pediatr. 2017;171(7):647–54.
Vallès Y, Artacho A, Pascual-García A, Ferrús ML, Gosalbes MJ, Abellán JJ, et al. Microbial succession in the gut: directional trends of taxonomic and functional change in a birth cohort of Spanish infants. PLoS Genet. 2014;10(6):e1004406.
Binns C, Lee M, Low WY. The long-term public health benefits of breastfeeding. Asia Pac J Public Health. 2016;28(1):7–14.
Dieterich CM, Felice JP, O’Sullivan E, Rasmussen KM. Breastfeeding and health outcomes for the mother-infant dyad. Pediatr Clin N Am. 2013;60(1):31–48.
WHO. Short-term effects of breastfeeding: a systematic review on the benefits of breastfeeding on diarrhoea and pneumonia mortality. 2019. https://www.who.int/maternal_child_adolescent/documents/breastfeeding_short_term_effects/en/. Accessed 22 January 2019.
WHO. Long-term effects of breastfeeding: a systematic review. 2019. https://www.who.int/maternal_child_adolescent/documents/breastfeeding_long_term_effects/en/. Accessed 22 January 2019.
Uwaezuoke SN, Eneh CI, Ndu IK. Relationship between exclusive breastfeeding and lower risk of childhood obesity: a narrative review of published evidence. Clin Med Insights Pediatr. 2017;11:1179556517690196.
Cabrera-Rubio R, Mira-Pascual L, Mira A, Collado MC. Impact of mode of delivery on the milk microbiota composition of healthy women. J Dev Orig Health Dis. 2016;7(1):54–60.
Cabrera-Rubio R, Collado MC, Laitinen K, Salminen S, Isolauri E, Mira A. The human milk microbiome changes over lactation and is shaped by maternal weight and mode of delivery. Am J Clin Nutr. 2012;96(3):544–51.
Kumar H, du Toit E, Kulkarni A, Aakko J, Linderborg KM, Zhang Y, et al. Distinct patterns in human milk microbiota and fatty acid profiles across specific geographic locations. Front Microbiol. 2016;7:1619.
Urbaniak C, Angelini M, Gloor GB, Reid G. Human milk microbiota profiles in relation to birthing method, gestation and infant gender. Microbiome. 2016;4:1.
Moossavi S, Sepehri S, Robertson B, Bode L, Goruk S, Field CJ, et al. Composition and variation of the human milk microbiota are influenced by maternal and early-life factors. Cell Host Microbe. 2019;25(2):324–35 e4.
Oksanen J, Blanchet FG, Friendly M, Kindt R, Legendre P, McGlinn D, et al. vegan: Community Ecology Package. 2019. https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=vegan. Accessed 23 January 2019.
Najafi F, Hasani J, Izadi N, Hashemi-Nazari S-S, Namvar Z, Mohammadi S, et al. The effect of prepregnancy body mass index on the risk of gestational diabetes mellitus: a systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis. Obes Rev. 2019;20(3):472–86.
Sze MA, Schloss PD. Looking for a signal in the noise: revisiting obesity and the microbiome. mBio. 2016;7(4):e01018–6.
Rodríguez JM. The origin of human milk bacteria: is there a bacterial entero-mammary pathway during late pregnancy and lactation? Adv Nutr. 2014;5(6):779–84.
Jeurink PV, van Bergenhenegouwen J, Jiménez E, Knippels LMJ, Fernández L, Garssen J, et al. Human milk: a source of more life than we imagine. Benef Microbes. 2013;4(1):17–30.
Biagi E, Quercia S, Aceti A, Beghetti I, Rampelli S, Turroni S, et al. The bacterial ecosystem of human milk and Infant’s mouth and gut. Front Microbiol. 2017;8:1214.
Gupta VK, Paul S, Dutta C. Geography, ethnicity or subsistence-specific variations in human microbiome composition and diversity. Front Microbiol. 2017;8:1162.
Drago L, Toscano M, De Grandi R, Grossi E, Padovani EM, Peroni DG. Microbiota network and mathematic microbe mutualism in colostrum and mature milk collected in two different geographic areas: Italy versus Burundi. ISME J. 2017;11(4):875–84.
Lackey KA, Williams JE, Meehan CL, Zachek JA, Benda ED, Price WJ, et al. What’s normal? Microbiomes in human milk and infant feces are related to each other but vary geographically: The INSPIRE Study. Front Nutr. 2019;6:45.
Huttenhower C, Gevers D, Knight R, et al. Structure, function and diversity of the healthy human microbiome. Nature. 2012;486:207–14.
Wang S, Li N, Zou H, Wu M. Gut microbiome-based secondary metabolite biosynthetic gene clusters detection in Parkinson’s disease. Neurosci Lett. 2019;696:93–8.
Osbourn A. Secondary metabolic gene clusters: evolutionary toolkits for chemical innovation. Trends Genet. 2010;26(10):449–57.
O’Brien J, Wright GD. An ecological perspective of microbial secondary metabolism. Curr Opin Biotechnol. 2011;22(4):552–8.
Morton JT, Marotz C, Washburne A, Silverman J, Zaramela LS, Edlund A, et al. Establishing microbial composition measurement standards with reference frames. Nat Commun. 2019;10(1):2719.
Stämmler F, Gläsner J, Hiergeist A, Holler E, Weber D, Oefner PJ, et al. Adjusting microbiome profiles for differences in microbial load by spike-in bacteria. Microbiome. 2016;4(1):28.
Jian C, Luukkonen P, Yki-Järvinen H, Salonen A, Korpela K. Quantitative PCR provides a simple and accessible method for quantitative microbiota profiling. PLoS One. 2020;15(1):e0227285.
Ley SH, O’Connor DL, Retnakaran R, Hamilton JK, Sermer M, Zinman B, et al. Impact of maternal metabolic abnormalities in pregnancy on human milk and subsequent infant metabolic development: methodology and design. BMC Public Health. 2010;10:590.
Ley SH, Hanley AJ, Sermer M, Zinman B, O’Connor DL. Associations of prenatal metabolic abnormalities with insulin and adiponectin concentrations in human milk. Am J Clin Nutr. 2012;95(4):867–74.
LeMay-Nedjelski L, Copeland J, Wang PW, Butcher J, Unger S, Stintzi A, et al. Methods and strategies to examine the human breastmilk microbiome. Methods Mol Biol. 1849;2018:63–86.
Caporaso JG, Lauber CL, Walters WA, Berg-Lyons D, Huntley J, Fierer N, et al. Ultra-high-throughput microbial community analysis on the Illumina HiSeq and MiSeq platforms. ISME J. 2012;6(8):1621–4.
Edgar RC. Search and clustering orders of magnitude faster than BLAST. Bioinforma Oxf Engl. 2010;26(19):2460–1.
Wang Q, Garrity GM, Tiedje JM, Cole JR. Naïve Bayesian classifier for rapid assignment of rRNA sequences into the new bacterial taxonomy. Appl Environ Microbiol. 2007;73(16):5261–7.
Price LB, Liu CM, Melendez JH, Frankel YM, Engelthaler D, Aziz M, et al. Community analysis of chronic wound bacteria using 16S rRNA gene-based pyrosequencing: impact of diabetes and antibiotics on chronic wound microbiota. PLoS One. 2009;4(7):e6462.
McMurdie PJ, Holmes S. Phyloseq: a bioconductor package for handling and analysis of high-throughput phylogenetic sequence data. Pac Symp Biocomput. 2012:235–46.
Iwai S, Weinmaier T, Schmidt BL, Albertson DG, Poloso NJ, Dabbagh K, et al. Piphillin: improved prediction of metagenomic content by direct inference from human microbiomes. PLoS One. 2016;11(11):e0166104.
LLN is a recipient of a Canadian Institutes of Health Research Doctoral Award (The Frederick Banting and Charles Best Canada Graduate Scholarship Doctoral Award (CGS-D)). We would like to thank Michael Jory for his assistance in setting up bioinformatic software in our laboratory.
CIHR MOP #125997; CDA Operating Grant #OG-3-09-2393; CIHR FDN #143233. The sources of funding had no role in the design or conduct of the research study, statistical analysis, data interpretation or writing of the manuscript.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Written informed consent was obtained from all women and the study protocol was approved by the Sinai Health Human Research Ethics Board.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
16S rRNA studies examining the association of maternal body mass index (BMI) and mode of delivery on the milk microbiota of women delivering healthy term-born infants. Note: Only studies in which mature milk was collected between 1 week - 6 months post-partum and BMI and mode of delivery were investigated were included to more accurately compare with our own findings.
The intersection of pre-pregnancy BMI and gestational glucose tolerance status.
Proportion of samples containing the top 5 phyla and top 10 genera.
The association between maternal characteristics and milk microbiota alpha-diversity. Pre-pregnancy BMI and post-partum BMI models were adjusted for maternal glucose tolerance status, mode of delivery, DNA extraction and PCR sequencing batches. Ethnicity was adjusted for DNA extraction and PCR sequencing batch effects.
Visual representation of the association between maternal characteristics and milk microbiota beta-diversity (weighted UniFrac metric). Principal coordinate analysis (PCoA, weighted UniFrac) plots comparing microbiota composition based on (A) maternal glucose tolerance, (B) mode of delivery, (C) pre-pregnancy BMI, (D) 3-month post-partum BMI, and (E) ethnicity. PCoA using the weighted UniFrac distance metric showed that microbiota profiles did not separate based on maternal clinical data. No statistically significant findings were observed between beta-diversity and glucose tolerance, mode of delivery, BMI, or ethnicity. Abbreviations: GDM, gestational diabetes mellitus, IGT, impaired glucose tolerance; CS, C-section.
Visual representation of the association between maternal characteristics and milk microbiota beta-diversity (Bray-Curtis metric). Principal coordinate analysis (PCoA, Bray-Curtis dissimilarity) plots comparing microbiota composition based on (A) maternal glucose tolerance, (B) mode of delivery, (C) pre-pregnancy BMI, (D) 3-month post-partum BMI, and (E) ethnicity. PCoA using the Bray-Curtis dissimilarity showed that microbiota profiles separated based on pre-pregnancy BMI (R2 = 0.037, p = 0.031), even after adjustment for maternal glucose tolerance status, mode of delivery, DNA extraction batch, and PCR sequencing batch. No statistically significant findings were observed between beta-diversity and glucose tolerance, mode of delivery, 3-month post-partum BMI or ethnicity. Abbreviations: GDM, gestational diabetes mellitus, IGT, impaired glucose tolerance; CS, C-section.
Examining the association between maternal characteristics and the milk microbiota beta-diversity. Statistically significant p-values (p < 0.05) are indicated with asterisks (*). 1Adjusted for maternal glucose tolerance status, mode of delivery, DNA extraction and PCR sequencing batches. Maternal glucose tolerance and mode of delivery were further adjusted for pre-pregnancy BMI. 2Ethnicity was adjusted for DNA extraction and PCR sequencing batch effects. An interaction term between BMI and glucose tolerance (Pre-pregnancy BMI-Maternal glucose tolerance status) was adjusted for batch effects and mode of delivery. The interaction term was found to be non-significant (as shown) and statistical models were re-run with it removed.
Associations between maternal characteristics and the top 5 phyla and top 10 genera: Results where pairwise comparisons were statistically significant but group effects were not. Separate Poisson regression models were run for pre-pregnancy BMI and 3-month post-partum BMI, while adjusting for maternal glucose tolerance status, mode of delivery, DNA extraction batch, and PCR sequencing batch. Statistically significant pairwise findings shown only (p < 0.05). Group effect thresholds [p ≤ 0.022 for phylum, p ≤ 0.017 for genus] were not significant, however, pairwise comparisons were (p < 0.05). All models were run testing an interaction term between BMI and maternal glucose tolerance status; this was removed from models if non-significant. Abbreviations: confidence interval, CI; incidence rate ratio, IRR; GDM, gestational diabetes.
Associations between ethnicity and the top 5 phyla and top 10 genera: Results where pairwise comparisons were statistically significant but group effects were not. Ethnicity was investigated for all taxa and models were adjusted for DNA extraction and PCR sequencing batch effects. Group effect thresholds [p ≤ 0.022 for phylum, p ≤ 0.017 for genus] were not significant, however, pairwise comparisons were (p < 0.05). No statistically significant associations were found between ethnicity and any phylum-level taxa. Abbreviations: confidence interval, CI; incidence rate ratio, IRR.
The association between maternal characteristics and the top 5 phyla. PreBMI, Pre-pregnancy BMI; PostBMI, Post-partum BMI.
The association between maternal characteristics and the top 10 genera. PreBMI, Pre-pregnancy BMI; PostBMI, Post-partum BMI.
Relative abundance of top 20 KEGG pathways across milk samples.
Examining the association between maternal metadata and KEGG ortholog beta-diversity. Pre-pregnancy BMI and post-partum BMI models were adjusted for maternal glucose tolerance status, mode of delivery, DNA extraction and PCR sequencing batches. Maternal glucose tolerance and mode of delivery were further adjusted for pre-pregnancy BMI. Ethnicity was adjusted for DNA extraction and PCR sequencing batch effects. Statistical significance p < 0.05.
Statistically significant differentially-expressed predicted functional pathway. Pre-pregnancy BMI result was adjusted for maternal glucose tolerance status, mode of delivery, DNA extraction and PCR sequencing batches. BMI_cat = Pre-pregnancy BMI.
Complete results from MaAsLin2 (KEGG pathways). BMI_cat = Pre-pregnancy BMI.
Statistically significant association between the KEGG pathway, “Biosynthesis of secondary metabolites”, and pre-pregnancy BMI (obese sub-category). BMI_cat = Pre-pregnancy BMI.
Principal coordinate analysis (PCoA) plots examining negative controls compared to human milk samples. (A) Weighted UniFrac distances comparing microbiota composition based on negative controls and milk samples. (B) Bray Curtis dissimilarity comparing microbiota composition based negative controls and milk samples. Negative control = sterile water
Flow diagram of subject participation at each time point.
About this article
Cite this article
LeMay-Nedjelski, L., Butcher, J., Ley, S.H. et al. Examining the relationship between maternal body size, gestational glucose tolerance status, mode of delivery and ethnicity on human milk microbiota at three months post-partum. BMC Microbiol 20, 219 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12866-020-01901-9
- Human milk
- Body mass index
- Gestational diabetes
- Impaired glucose tolerance
- Mode of delivery
- Vaginal delivery
- Caesarean delivery