Measurement of microbial activity in soil by colorimetric observation of in situ dye reduction: an approach to detection of extraterrestrial life
© Crawford et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2002
Received: 7 May 2002
Accepted: 31 July 2002
Published: 31 July 2002
Detecting microbial life in extraterrestrial locations is a goal of space exploration because of ecological and health concerns about possible contamination of other planets with earthly organisms, and vice versa. Previously we suggested a method for life detection based on the fact that living entities require a continual input of energy accessed through coupled oxidations and reductions (an electron transport chain). We demonstrated using earthly soils that the identification of extracted components of electron transport chains is useful for remote detection of a chemical signature of life. The instrument package developed used supercritical carbon dioxide for soil extraction, followed by chromatography or electrophoresis to separate extracted compounds, with final detection by voltammetry and tandem mass-spectrometry.
Here we used Earth-derived soils to develop a related life detection system based on direct observation of a biological redox signature. We measured the ability of soil microbial communities to reduce artificial electron acceptors. Living organisms in pure culture and those naturally found in soil were shown to reduce 2,3-dichlorophenol indophenol (DCIP) and the tetrazolium dye 2,3-bis(2-methoxy-4-nitro-5-sulfophenyl)-2H-tetrazolium-5-carboxanilide inner salt (XTT). Uninoculated or sterilized controls did not reduce the dyes. A soil from Antarctica that was determined by chemical signature and DNA analysis to be sterile also did not reduce the dyes.
Observation of dye reduction, supplemented with extraction and identification of only a few specific signature redox-active biochemicals such as porphyrins or quinones, provides a simplified means to detect a signature of life in the soils of other planets or their moons.
The detection of microbial life in extraterrestrial locations is an important goal of human exploration of space because of ecological and health concerns about possible contamination of other planets with earthly organisms, and vice versa [1, 2]. Several indirect methods for detecting extraterrestrial life have been proposed in the prior literature. These include (a) examining the ratios of stable isotopes in important elements such as carbon and sulphur for discrimination against heavy isotopes and selective use of the lighter isotopes, (b) microscopic observations of highly organized or specifically-shaped structures [3, 4], (c) examination of soils for the presence of specific types of organic moieties , and (d) the detection of chiral molecules in extraterrestrial samples [6–12].
Previously we suggested a thermodynamic approach to the detection of life. Since living entities require a continual source of usable energy, we should be able to detect a chemical signature of life in the form of mixtures of redox molecules such as porphyrins, quinones, and flavins that transport electrons along redox gradients between electron donors and acceptors . We examined methods to extract and detect the components of electron transport chains that might be used to indicate the presence of life on site in extraterrestrial locations. Our experiments showed this to be a promising approach, though instrument development and miniaturization for this purpose will be challenging .
Here we discuss the possibility of a related, but simpler approach for detecting life that will measure the actual existence of functioning electron transport chains. This can theoretically be done remotely and on site using robotically collected extraterrestrial soil samples. The method involves detection of actual activity of respiratory electron transport using artificial electron acceptors such as DCIP and tetrazolium dyes such as XTT. DCIP, for example, couples directly with NADH or NADPH to form DCIPH2 and NAD+ or NADP+, making it an ideal electron transport chain indicator . XTT has been used to measure microbial respiratory activity in complex natural environments . Respiratory dyes have been used commercially for many years in the Biolog™ system to help identify pure cultures of microorganisms by their patterns of oxidation of multiple organic substrates . Biolog™ also has been used to characterize oxidation capabilities of soil microbial communities . Rodriquez, et al.  used the redox dye 5-cyano-2,3-ditolyl tetrazolium chloride (CTC) for direct epifluorescent microscopic enumeration of respiring bacteria in environmental samples. The oxidized form of CTC is nearly colorless and non-fluorescent. Oxidized CTC was observed to be reduced by biological electron transport systems, forming a fluorescent, insoluble CTC-formazan. The formazan accumulated intracellularly and could be visualized by epifluorescence microscopy in wet-mount preparations, on polycarbonate membrane filter surfaces, or directly in some biofilms. Thus, coupled with more limited analyses for specific electron transport molecules (e.g., porphyrins or quinones), the use of respiratory dyes for detection of active electron transport in the biological redox range could provide very convincing evidence for life in extraterrestrial locations. This approach would obviously only detect presently living entities, but these could include dormant life forms such as spores that might germinate and grow using added nutrients.
Examination of the presence of a chemical signature of life in various soils
Confirmation of the presence of bacterial life in terrestrial soil samples.
Plate Count1 (viable cells/g soil)
Fluorescence2 (ng DNA/g soil)
2.74 × 104
Beacon Valley, Antarctica
Lake Boney Basin, Antarctica
4.2 × 103
Blank (reagents only)
Redox dye reduction by various soils
Energy use by living organisms directs our experimental design for seeking signs of extraterrestrial life. In terrestrial biological systems, energy is tapped via stepwise electron transport between electron donors and acceptors via an electron transport chain. Applying this principle universally, we should be able to detect the chemical components of electron transport chains or electron transport itself as a signature of life.
Our assumptions about the centrality of electron transport processes to life led us to a direct experimental approach for detection of life. We were able to measure actual electron transport in the redox range between -1.0 and +1.0 V in a microbe-poor soil, in the presence of air, and both with and without additions of an electron donor (dilute nutrient broth). The respiratory electron-accepting dyes DCIP and XTT were used to "short-circuit" microbial electron transport, and this was observed (dye reduction) by visible spectroscopy. This method might entail some site-specific challenges in environments that are different from those on Earth, especially in developing appropriate controls for abiotic processes. NASA learned this lesson from the Viking biology mission to Mars. In the Viking's gas exchange experiment, water vapor exposed to the Martian soil released O2, but possibly only as a result of the activity of powerful soil oxidants that also might have been responsible for the chemical reactivity seen in other Viking biology experiments . A molecule such as DCIP or XTT might be destroyed by oxidation in the presence of such soils. However, soil samples taken from borings beneath the surface, which is exposed to high energy, oxidant-generating ultraviolet radiation, or from other protected areas, might not be so destructive of organic compounds. Such stability problems should not be of such concern for extraterrestrial sites such as Europa or Titan. Thus, our ability, confirmed here, to detect actual electron transport within the redox potential range of life processes, and to observe simultaneously some of the signature chemical structures involved, offers a promising direct approach to detecting the capability of living entities in soil on Earth or elsewhere in our solar system to move electrons between universal donors and acceptors and obtain energy to support replication.
Since we are not yet able to test this approach extraterrestrially, we validated our proposed detection method using pure microbial cultures and microbe-poor soils collected on Earth. A select group of signature chemicals were extracted from an organic-poor soil (Figure 1) and identified with instruments that eventually can be miniaturized for use on space exploration missions [13, 21, 22]. Actual electron transport by living cells was confirmed by use of two specific dyes (DCIP and XTT) that short-circuit respiratory electron transport chains. This was demonstrated using a pure strain of the common earthly soil microorganism, Pseudomonas putida (Figure 6), and with native soil microorganisms within two nutrient-supplemented soil matrixes (Figures 3,4,5). We easily detected a signature of biological electron transport within a biologically poor, sandy soil containing about 30,000 cultivable cells per gram (Idaho red sand), and also from a soil from the extreme environment of Lake Boney Basin, Antarctica (Table 1). Though the Boney Basin soil readily reduced XTT, it only very slowly reduced DCIP (data not shown), and the rate of reduction was not significantly different between untreated soil and killed controls. Since DCIP and XTT have different redox potentials, and XTT in our work appears to generally be more easily reduced by soil microbial communities, this shows a need to use more than one respiratory dye in this type of experiment.
Our observations also indicate that in soils from extreme environments, one may expect differences in their patterns of dye reduction that probably reflect differences in their community phylogenetic compositions. A soil from Beacon Valley, Antarctica that showed no DNA at our detection limit also showed no dye reduction activity with either dye. This soil appears to be sterile by our method of life detection; certainly it contains fewer microbial cells than our detection limit. Further investigations of this soil are thus warranted. For the Idaho red sand, assuming 30,000 cells represent about 1% of actual biomass in the soil, the detection limit of our method should be about 3,000,000 cells/g. Though the amount of DNA observed in the Lake Boney Basin soil was actually higher than seen in the Idaho red sand, the microbial counts were lower (Table 1). This shows once again the limitation of viable counts, which only count organisms that grow on the specific medium employed. It is well known that most bacteria in nature cannot be cultured. Our work indicates there is probably a more dominant non-cultivable microbial community in the Antarctic soil compared to the Idaho soil, since DNA analysis indicated high numbers of microorganisms that were not reflected in viable count data.
We need to improve the current detection limit for organic moieties (Figure 1), estimated at 3 × 106 cells per gram of soil. Processing larger quantities of soil could easily increase sensitivity for detection of redox molecules. Supplementing soils with appropriate electron donors and acceptors could stimulate extensive growth of low numbers of indigenous organisms. In theory, even a few cells/gram of soil might be detected using this approach. The former procedure might be accomplished by using a "flow-through" soil extractor that could receive multiple soil additions and concentrate the extracted residues prior to downstream analysis. The latter procedure could be implemented by using a microtiter plate format similar that employed by Biolog™, where hundreds of potential electron donors could be examined simultaneously and the results (dye reduction) read by an on-board UV-visible spectral scanner designed for scanning microtiter plates. Examples of donor-acceptor combinations might include: simple sugars and/or amino acids or other organic molecules in the presence of oxygen or nitrate (organisms capable of heterotrophic respiration), hydrogen and ferric ions or oxidized iron minerals (chemoautotrophic hydrogen oxidizers), organic acids and ferric ions or oxidized iron minerals (heterotrophic iron reducers), bicarbonate/carbonate and trace minerals in the presence and absence of light (photosynthetic organisms), carbon dioxide and a reduced metal such as ferrous ions (chemoautotrophs), ammonium ion and bicarbonate/carbonate (ammonia oxidizers), etc. The combinations could be adapted to the environment under study, such as Mars (perhaps an iron-dominated energy system).
In this work, we emphasized that during validation on Earth of any life detection method there is a requirement for control measurements that corroborate earthly results of assays that might be carried out remotely on other planets. We chose measurements of DNA (present in all earthly life) and readily cultivable bacteria (present in most earthly soils) for validating our specific redox chemistry based approach. In the future, as we and others work to increase the sensitivity of this life detection approach toward values needed for the extreme environments on Earth and places such as the regolith of Mars, the simple controls we used should be supplemented by a number of others. These could include controls such as direct microscopic counts of active and inactive bacteria , extraction and quantitation of ATP , extraction and analysis of fatty acids , real-time PCR of universal 16S rDNA markers , and/or use of a larger variety of culture media, including dilute organic media, in place of or in addition to plate count agar . All of these approaches also have problems, such as the possible presence in soil of biological molecules that are not associated with living cells, the always-present inability of microbiologists to culture most of the bacteria present in soil, and the often unpredictable performance of PCR primers. However, the sum of such multiple controls would build toward ultimate confidence in the sensitivity of this or any other life detection technique.
Because there is great diversity among habitats for microbial life on the Earth, and sterility of an earthly soil is rare, it would be desirable to examine as many as possible of these environments to determine the absolute reliability of our techniques for use extraterrestrially. Unfortunately, we cannot sample all possible terrestrial environments on Earth, or even a small fraction of them. We feel the diversity we have examined is sufficient to indicate the value of our approach, particularly since one of these extreme environments we did examine (Beacon Valley, Antarctica) appears to be sterile. We also cannot examine all known heterotrophic bacteria stored in culture collections to confirm that all or most of them effect dye reduction. However, the many years of experience using the Biolog™ system, which employs respiratory dyes to indicate microbial metabolism [17, 18], is strong support for our hypothesis that respiratory dye reduction is a robust and conclusive assay for heterotrophic life in soil. Further validation efforts may show that observation of redox cycling of artificial electron acceptors of appropriate redox potentials may be sufficient in itself as a signature of life, greatly simplifying instrumentation requirements for extraterrestrial missions in our solar system and beyond.
Coupled with limited analyses for specific electron transport molecules (e.g., porphyrins and/or quinones), the use of respiratory dyes for detection of electron transport in the biological redox range could provide very convincing evidence for life in extraterrestrial locations.
As detailed in our prior work , the following compounds were used as representative examples of electron transport chain components. Protoporphyrin IX, hemin, hematin, and nicotinamide (vitamin B3) were purchased from Aldrich (Milwaukee, WI). Nicotinamide-adenine dinucleotide (NAD), riboflavin (vitamin B2), flavin mononucleotide (FMN), flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD), and DCIP were purchased from Sigma (St. Louis, MO). 2,3-Dimethoxy-5-methyl-,4-benzoquinone (coenzyme Q0) was purchased from Fluka (Buchs, Switzerland). XTT was purchased from TCI America, Inc. (Portland, OR). The other chemicals and solvents used were of the highest available purity.
Natural sand from dune areas of southern Idaho (Idaho red sand), poor in organic content and rich in oxidized iron minerals, was used as a life-positive soil and surrogate for extraterrestrial soils. As a control we used cleaned, highly pure silica sand purchased from Fisher Scientific. These soils are described in our previous paper . Other extraterrestrial surrogate soils were collected from Beacon Valley and Lake Boney Basin, Antarctica. The soil from Beacon Valley was from an area where higher organisms such as nematodes have never been observed.
Extraction of soil organic moieties
Soil samples of 5 to 15 g were used for supercritical fluid extraction (SFE) with supercritical CO2 (SCCO2). Samples were first hydrolyzed in 5 to 10 ml of acetone containing 2 M NH4OH under ultrasound agitation (water bath at 160 watts) for 1 h at room temperature. Nitrogen blown over the sample then evaporated the solvents. The SFE extraction was performed with the dry sample within one day to avoid any degradation of redox compounds. A piece of Whatman glass fiber filter paper (1.0 μm pore size) was cut into a 0.8 cm diameter circle and placed at the outlet end of a 10-ml SFE extraction cell to retain large particles. A hydrolyzed sample (10 ml) was then packed into the vessel until it was full. Exactly 1.0 ml of 25% (v/v) trimethylamine in methanol as modifier was added to the sample, and the vessel was immediately connected to the SFE system. The extraction pressure was set at 300 atm, the oven temperature at 35°C, and the outlet valve temperature at 60°C. After a 15 min static extraction, a dynamic extraction was started until approximately 30 ml of liquid CO2 passed through the SFE cell . The flow rate was controlled at 5 to 10 ml/min by the outlet valve. In order to achieve maximum recovery, the SFE procedure was repeated again under identical conditions.
Separations were performed using a Hewlett Packard HP-1090 HPLC (Avondale, PA). Samples of 20 to 50 μL were injected onto a Discovery Amide C16 or Discovery C18 reverse phase column (15 cm × 4.6 mm, 5 μm, Supelco, Bellefonte, PA), and analytes were separated using the ion-pair chromatographic method. Solvent A was 5 mM tetrabutylammonium phosphate, 30 mM KH2PO4, and 4% acetonitrile (V/V). Solvent B was 100% acetonitrile. Runs were performed over 35 min with gradient elution of 0 to 40% B, then with static elution over 35 to 40 min with 60% A/40% B, followed by 40 to 42 min with 100% A and a post-run wash of 5 min at a flow rate of 1.0 ml/min . Detectors used were a tandem diode array detector (DAD) and dual carbon electrode amperometric detector (ECD).
Electrospray tandem mass-spectrometry
The identities of signature species present in extracts were confirmed by negative or positive electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry (Quattro II, Micromass Ltd., UK). Samples were delivered into the source at a flow rate of 5 μl/min using a syringe pump (Harvard Apparatus, South Natick, MA) or directly from a HPLC column, with effluent from the column split 1:100. A potential of 2.5 to 3 kV was applied to the electrospray needle. The sample cone was kept at an average of 15 V. The counter electrode, skimmer, and RF (radio frequency) lens potentials were tuned to maximize the ion beam for a given solvent. The resolution of the detector was 15,000, and the source temperature was kept constant at 80°C. The instrument was calibrated using a polyethylene glycol solution. All spectra were an average of 10 to 15 scans.
Biomass and DNA analysis in soil
The numbers of cultivable soil microorganisms were estimated by standard plate count and serial dilution methods. Standard plate count medium (PCM) was used to culture bacteria from soil samples . DNA was extracted from different soils using the FastPrep DNA spin kit from Qbiogene, Inc. (Carlsbad, CA). The concentration of DNA was estimated by measuring fluorescence at 520 nm. Fluorescence was measured after staining the sample with Pico Green fluorescent dye (Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR). Our detection limit was about 1 ng of DNA in 1 g of soil.
DCIP and XTT reduction assays
Working in a sterile laminar flow hood, we added 2.0 g of soil, 16.0 mL of sterile 100 mM phosphate buffer (pH 7.5), 2 mL of 100X Nutrient Broth as a biological reductant (Difco), and 1.0 mL of 1 mM DCIP to a sterile 25 mL serum bottle. Bottles were plugged and capped with sterile closures and shaken at room temperature for required experimental time. Periodically, samples (1.0 mL) were removed aseptically and centrifuged to remove solids. The absorbance of the filtrate was measured at 600 nm. Concentrations of DCIP (oxidized) were calculated using a molar extinction coefficient of ε = 21.0 × 103 M-1 cm-1. Reoxidation of DCIPH2 was negligible under our experimental conditions. Samples were run in triplicate.
Reduction of XTT was monitored similarly as described for DCIP, except we measured the increase in absorbance at 465 nm resulting from reduction of the colorless oxidized dye to an orange product .
The work described here was partially performed at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, under contract with the National Aeronautic and Space Administration (award 1212404). We thank Sarah Koerber for editorial assistance. We thank Dorota Parazinska, Andy Parsons, Diana Wall, and Colorado State University for assisting in the collection of soils from Antarctica.
- Scher S, Packer E, Sagan C: Biological contamination of Mars I. Survival of terrestrial microorganisms in simulated Martian environments. Life Sci Space Res. 1964, 2: 352-6.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Horneck G, Facius R, Reitz G, Rettberg P, Baumstark-Khan C, Gerzer R: Critical issues in connection with human planetary missions: protection of and from the environment. Acta Astronaut. 2001, 49: 279-288. 10.1016/S0094-5765(01)00106-0.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- McKay DS, Gibson EK, Thomas-Keprta KL, Vali H, Romanek CS, Clemett SJ, Chiller XDF, Maechling CR, Zare RN: Search for past life on Mars: possible relic biogenic activity in Martian meteorite ALH84001. Science. 1996, 273: 924-990.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Thomas-Keprta KL, Clemett SJ, Bazylinski DA, Kirschvink JL, McKay DS, Wentworth SJ, Vali H, Gibson EK, McKay MF, Romanek CS: Special Feature: Truncated hexa-octahedral magnetite crystals in ALH84001: presumptive biosignatures. PNAS. 2001, 98: 2164-2169. 10.1073/pnas.051500898.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Benner SA, Matveeva LN, Devine KG, Powell DH: The missing organic molecules on Mars. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2000, 97: 2425-2430. 10.1073/pnas.040539497.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bailey J, Chrysostomou A, Hough JH, Gledhill TM, McCall A, Clark S, Menard F, Tamura M: Circular polarization in star-formation regions. Science. 1998, 281: 672-674. 10.1126/science.281.5377.672.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Brack A, Spach G: Search for chiral molecules and optical activity in extraterrestrial systems, example of Titan. Biosystems. 1987, 20: 95-98. 10.1016/0303-2647(87)90024-4.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Cronin JR, Pizzarello S: Enantiomeric excesses in meteoritic amino acids. Science. 1997, 275: 951-955. 10.1126/science.275.5302.951.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Donn B: Comets: chemistry and chemical evolution. J Mol Evol. 1982, 18: 157-160.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Engel MH, Macko SA: Isotopic evidence for extraterrestrial non-racemic amino acids in the Murchison meteorite. Nature. 1997, 389: 265-268. 10.1038/38460.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Thiemann W: Life and chirality beyond the earth. Orig Life. 1975, 6: 475-481.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Whittet DC: Is extraterrestrial organic matter relevant to the origin of life on Earth?. Orig Life Evol Biosph. 1997, 27: 249-262. 10.1023/A:1006534500363.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Crawford RL, Paszczynski A, Lang Q, Cheng IF, Barnes B, Anderson TJ, Wells R, Wai C, Corti G, Allenbach L, Erwin DP, Park J, Assefi T, Mojarradi M: In search of the molecules of life. Icarus. 2001, 154: 531-539. 10.1006/icar.2001.6714.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lang Q, Cheng IF, Wai CM, Paszczynski A, Crawford RL, Barnes B, Anderson TJ, Wells R, Corti G, Allenbach L, Erwin DP, Assefi T, Mojarradi M: Supercritical fluid extraction and high-performance liquid chromatography-diode array-electrochemical detection of signature redox compounds from sand and soil samples. Anal Biochem. 2002, 301: 225-234. 10.1006/abio.2001.5502.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Tang HT, Hajizadah K, Halsall NB, Heinemann WR: Flow-injection analysis with electrochemical detection of reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide using 2,6-dichlorophenol as a redox coupling agent. Anal Biochem. 1991, 192: 243-250.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Roslev P, King GM: Application of a tetrazolium salt with a water-soluble formazan as an indicator of viability of respiring bacteria. Appl Environ Microbiol. 1993, 59: 2891-2896.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Muller AK, Rasmussen LD, Sorensen SJ: Adaptation of the bacterial community to mercury contamination. FEMS Microbiol Lett. 2001, 204: 49-53. 10.1016/S0378-1097(01)00376-7.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nedoluha PC, Owens S, Russek-Cohen E, Westhoff DC: Effect of sampling method on the representative recovery of microorganisms from the surfaces of aquacultured finfish. J Food Prot. 2001, 64: 1515-1520.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Rodriguez GG, Phipps D, Ishiguro K, Ridgway HF: Use of a fluorescent redox probe for direct visualization of actively respiring bacteria. Appl Environ Microbiol. 1992, 58: 1801-1808.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Quinn RC, Zent AP: Peroxide-modified titanium dioxide: a chemical analog of putative Martian soil oxidants. Orig Life Evol Biosph. 1999, 29: 59-72. 10.1023/A:1006506022182.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Henry CE: The incredible shrinking mass spectrometers. Anal Chem News Features. 1999, 264A-268A.Google Scholar
- Hunt LD, Glavin DP, Bada JL, Mathies RA: Microfabricated capillary electrophoresis amino acid chirality analyzer for extraterrestrial exploration. Anal Chem. 1999, 71: 4000-4006. 10.1021/ac9903959.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bjorkman KM, Karl DM: A novel method for the measurement of dissolved adenosine and guanosine triphosphate in aquatic habitats: applications to marine microbial ecology. J Microbiol Methods. 2001, 47: 159-167. 10.1016/S0167-7012(01)00301-3.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Litchfield CD, Irby A, Kis-Papo T, Oren A: Comparisons of the polar lipid and pigment profiles of two solar salterns located in Newark, California, USA, and Eilat, Israel. Extremophiles. 2000, 4: 259-265. 10.1007/s007920070011.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Stubner S: Enumeration of 16S rDNA of Desulfotomaculum lineage 1 in rice field soil by real-time PCR with SybrGreen detection. J Microbiol Methods. 2002, 50: 155-164. 10.1016/S0167-7012(02)00024-6.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Crocker FH, Fredrickson JK, White DC, Ringelberg DB, Balkwill DL: Phylogenetic and physiological diversity of Arthrobacter strains isolated from unconsolidated subsurface sediments. Microbiology. 2000, 146: 1295-1310.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Smart NG, Carleson TE, Kast T, Clifford AA, Burford MD, Wai CM: Solubility of chelating agents and metal containing compounds in supercritical fluid carbon dioxide–a review. Talanta. 1997, 44: 137-150. 10.1016/S0039-9140(96)02008-5.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Payne SM, Ames BN: A procedure for rapid extraction and high-pressure liquid chromatographic separation of the nucleotides and other small molecules from bacterial cells. Anal Biochem. 1982, 123: 151-161.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hattori T, Hattori R: The plate count method: an attempt to delineate the bacterial life in the microhabitat of soil. In Soil Biochemistry. Edited by: Bollag J-M and Stotzky G. 2000, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc., 10 (chapter 6):Google Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article: verbatim copying and redistribution of this article are permitted in all media for any purpose, provided this notice is preserved along with the article's original URL.