Table 2 Summary of the in vitro PDT studies using methylene blue, rose Bengal or curcumin on S. mutans, S. sanguis and C. albicans
From: In vitro effect photodynamic therapy with differents photosensitizers on cariogenic microorganisms
PS | Concentration | Inhibition | λ | Fluence | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(μg/ml) | (%) | (nm) | (J/cm2) | ||
S. mutans | |||||
Araújo et al. [33] | MB | 25 | 73 | ND | ND |
Our study | MB | 2.5 | 999.999 | 420–700 | 37 |
Costa et al. [34] | RB | 2.02 | 999.999 | 440–460 | 95 |
Our study | RB | 0,62 | 999.999 | 420–700 | 37 |
Araújo et al. [23] | CUR | 1500 | 99.9 | 450 | 5.7 |
Paschoal et al. [44] | CUR | 1473.5 | 60 | 450 | 72 |
Manoil et al. [45] | CUR | 0.73 | 95 % | 360–550 | 542 |
Our study | CUR | 160 | 999.999 | 420–700 | 37 |
S. sanguis | |||||
Chan et al. [37] | AM | 100 | 99–100 | 632.8 | 21.2 |
Our study | AM | 2.5 | 999.999 | 420–700 | 37 |
Pereira et al. [32] | RB | 5 | 9.9 | 455 | 95 |
Our study | RB | 0.62 | 999.999 | 420–700 | 37 |
Our study | CUR | 1500 | 999.999 | 420–700 | 37 |
Mattiello et al. [46] | TB | 200 | 84.32 | 660 | 10 |
C. albicans | |||||
Souza et al. [15] | AM | 100 | 99.9 | 660 | 39,5 |
Peloi et al. [14] 4 | AM | 22,5 | 95,14 | 663 | 6 |
Souza et al. [16] | AM | 100 | 88,6 | 685 | 28 |
Our study | AM | 160 | 99.999 | 420–700 | 37 |
Costa et al. [18] | RB | 23 | 9.9 | 455 | 95 |
Demidova et al. [47] | RB | 200 | 99,9999 | 525–555 | 80 |
Our study | RB | >1280 | <99.999 | 420–700 | 37 |
Andrade et al. [26] | CUR | 7,3 | 89.5 | 455 | 5,28 |
Dovigo et al. [48] | CUR | 14,8 | 85 | 440–460 | 18 |
Our study | CUR | >2460 | <99.999 | 420–700 | 37 |