Bmc Microbiology Transcriptional Analysis of Mycobacterium Fortuitum Cultures upon Hydrogen Peroxide Treatment Using the Novel Standard Rrna-p1

Background: The ability of an intracellular pathogen to establish infection depends on the capacity of the organism to survive and replicate inside the host. Mycobacterium fortuitum is a bacteria that contains genes involved in the detoxification of the oxygen reactive species such as those produced by the host during the infection. In this work, we investigate the effects of hydrogen peroxide on the transcription and expression of these genes by developing a real time quantitative PCR technique (qRT-PCR) using the ribosomal promoter region (rrnA-P1) as reference product for quantification of the mRNA levels.


Background
The genus Mycobacterium includes species found in a wide range of ecological niches. M. tuberculosis, M. leprae, and M. avium subsp. paratuberculosis, are pathogenic species causing clinical disease in humans or animals. Other species as M. smegmatis and M. phlei are saprophytes. In addition, an intermediate position is occupied by species opportunistic pathogens such as M. fortuitum, a rapidly growing mycobacteria that is ubiquitous in soil and water. This mycobacteria is known to cause cutaneous infection, typically in association with trauma or clinical procedures [1,2]. Due to its capacity to growth and to survive intracellularly, M. fortuitum has been previously used as a model for studying the intracellular killing of mycobacteria [3,4].
Most bacteria, when exposed to toxic oxygen metabolites, exhibit an adaptive response and express several genes involved in detoxification of oxygen reactive species, such as superoxide dismutases (SOD), catalases and peroxidases [5,6]. This type of adaptative response has been implicated in the intracellular survival of pathogenic mycobacteria, promoting their maintenance in the host [7][8][9].
The major pathogen, M. tuberculosis, produces an iron cofactored SOD encoded by the gene sodA [10] and a copper and zinc SOD encoded by the gene sodC [11] whose involvement in protection against oxidative stress of M. tuberculosis within macrophages is currently controversial [12,13]. SOD encoded by sodA is a major secreted protein [14] that inhibits host responses to M. tuberculosis [15]. The expression of genes sodA and sodC is considered constitutive and inducible respectively [15,16]. Homologues of these genes have been detected in several mycobacterial species, including M. fortuitum [13,17].
There are two classes of catalases identified in mycobacteria: the heat-labile catalase or T-catalase (coded by katG), which has also a peroxidase-like function, and the heatstable catalase or M-catalase (coded by katE). The catalase codified by katG is synthesized preferentially in response to oxidative stress whereas the catalase codified by katE is produced in response to nutrient depletion as occurs in the stationary phase of growth [18]. M. fortuitum produces both catalases however M. tuberculosis produces only Tcatalase whilst M. terrae only produces M-catalase [19]. The katG gene has been widely studied in M. tuberculosis [20,21]. The KatG protein contributes to the ability of M. tuberculosis to grow and survive within the infected host tissues [22] and is involved in the resistance of M. tuberculosis to the first-line antimicrobial drug isoniazid [23,24]. Due to their involvement in disease pathogenesis, both sodA and katG genes are considered virulence factors of M. tuberculosis [25].
The oxidative stress response in bacteria is linked to the iron metabolic pathway [26]. One of the proteins involved in that link is the ferric uptake regulator protein (FurA) an homologue of the Fur of E. coli, encoded by the furA gene [27]. The furA gene is located immediately upstream of the katG gene in M tuberculosis, an arrangement that appears to be common amongst mycobacterial genomes [28,29].
Only few studies have investigated the regulation of expression of detoxifying genes in mycobacteria. Two promoters have been detected that control katG expression in M. tuberculosis, one is located upstream of the furA gene and is co-transcribed with katG [30,31]. Moreover, FurA represses katG gene expression in M. tuberculosis and M. smegmatis [29] and autoregulates its own expression by binding to the Fur-A box, a 23 bp AT-rich sequence located upstream of furA gene, which is overlapping the -35 and -10 region of the corresponding promoter [32,33]. No studies have yet been published on the regulation of mycobacterial sod genes.
The genes sodA and katG have been previously studied by our group in M. fortuitum [17,34]. We have shown that protein SodA of M. fortuitum requires manganese as cofactor [17]. This mycobacteria has two genes encoding for two different enzymes with catalase-peroxidase activities, called katGI and katGII (KatGI and KatGII). KatGII is more related to the single M. tuberculosis KatG than KatGI [34]. Upstream of both genes we have also found copies of the furAI and furAII genes respectively [EMBL: Y17061 and Y17062]. The furAII-katGII spacer region spans only 33 nucleotides in the genome of M. fortuitum, thus suggesting that the two genes might be co-transcribed.
In this work we have further analyzed the transcriptional activity of katGII, furAII and sodA genes in M. fortuitum under oxidative stress. Putative promoters have been identified, and real-time quantitative PCR (qRT-PCR) applied to the transcriptional analysis of cultures, which have been exposed to hydrogen peroxide.
qRT-PCR technology has been widely used in the analysis of gene transcriptional activity due to its high efficiency, level of sensitivity and specificity [35][36][37]. Quantitative gene-expression assays using this technique are typically referenced to an internal control to account for differences in the RNA load. The conditions of the experimental design should not influence the detection level of the selected internal control. Thus the validation of reference controls is recommended in any such experimentation [38].
Two different products sigA [39][40][41] and rrs (16S rRNA) [42,43], have most often been used as reference standards in qRT-PCR assays involving mycobacteria. However both of these have disadvantages. sigA expression has been found to decrease threefold during entry of bacterial growth into the stationary phase [44]. Levels of rrs usually do not change during most phases of bacterial growth, however it is present in a much higher amounts than any mRNA in the cell [M. C. Nuñez & M. J. Garcia, unpublished results] probably because of its higher stability as part of the ribosomes, compared to the stability of other RNA molecules in the cytoplasm, which can cause problems with sensitivity.
Recently, our laboratory described [45] a putative new reference product (rrnA-P1) suitable for qRT-PCR. Here we demonstrate the usefulness of this promoter as reference in the qRT-PCR analysis of cultures of M. fortuitum during oxidative stress. This methodology may be applied to other quantitative gene-expression analysis of mycobacteria and other bacterial genera in order to evaluate the influence of any experimental treatment on the transcriptional level of gene expression.

Enzymatic activity upon oxidative stress of KatG and SodA proteins
The enzymatic activities of catalase-peroxidase and superoxide dismutase proteins were examined in the extracts collected from M. fortuitum cultures (see Methods). The results ( Figure 1a) indicated a low level of activity of the KatGI under each of the test conditions. Further analysis of the mRNA levels for katGI (gene coding for KatGI) was unsuccessful, probably due to the scarce expression level of that gene under the experimental conditions applied. The activity of KatGII remains similar from 30 to 120 minutes under 0.02 and 2 mM of H 2 O 2 ( Figure 1a). KatGII showed its lowest activity relative to the control at 30 min of treatment with 20 mM hydrogen peroxide. At this highest concentration, the catalase-peroxidase activity of Kat-GII increased from cultures treated during 30 min to cultures treated during 120 min (Figure 1a). See Additional file 1 for densitometry values.
The SodA enzymatic activity did not show detectable variation with the control comparing different extracts under all the conditions tested ( Figure 1b). This result is in agreement with the considered constitutive expression of the sodA gene [15].

Identification of the transcriptional start points (tsp) of the genes under study
We detected two putative transcriptional start points (tsp P1 and tsp P2) in each the three genes examined by RNA protection assay (RPA) ( Table 1a). Putative -35 and -10 boxes were identified according the consensus mycobacterial promoters previously described in the literature [46,47]. The presence of furAII-katGII co-transcripts was tested by standard RT-PCR. Co-transcripts furAII-katGII were detected in all the stress conditions tested (data not shown). These results are in agreement to those described previously in M. tuberculosis [30,33].

Validation of rrnA-P1 as reference product in qRT-PCR under stress conditions
The rrnA-P1 promoter-usage of M. fortuitum cultures treated with hydrogen peroxide was analyzed by primer extension (PE) [48,49]. The relative activities of the five rrn promoters of M. fortuitum, corresponding to different PE products, were determined by quantification of the radioactive levels for each of the conditions tested ( Figure  2a).
All the promoters were differentially expressed under each of the conditions tested with the exception of the rrnA-P1 promoter whose contribution to the pre-rRNA synthesis was less than 1%, and evenly maintained in each of the stress conditions tested (Figure 2a). These results suggested the suitability of the rrnA-P1 promoter as reference standard in qRT-PCR analysis of M. fortuitum under oxidative stress.
Protein activity of KatG and SodA using ND-PAGE gels Experiments were conducted to validate the usefulness of rrnA-P1 product as a reference in qRT-PCR, when M. fortuitum cultures were grown under oxidative stress. Validation of the rrnA-P1 promoter as a constitutive product was investigated using the derivation of the 2 -ΔΔCt equation as indicated in Methods: 2 -ΔCt (ΔCt = C t sample -C t control ). In this equation the control corresponded to the untreated culture, and the sample corresponded to each stress culture condition. The results are showed in the Figure 2b. No significant differences were found comparing data from all the culture conditions tested with the control (p = 0.445). This result validates the product corresponding to rrnA-P1 promoter as a reference in the analysis undertaken.

Analysis of the M. fortuitum gene expression upon oxidative stress
The transcription of katGII and sodA in M. fortuitum during the oxidative stress response was initially analyzed using Northern Blot assay ( Figure 3). The transcripts were detected by hybridization with internal probes corresponding to each of the genes. An internal probe of the rrs gene was also used to test the relative amount of RNA fixed on the filter ( Figure 3). A single band was detected per each probe at the expected sizes: 1.5 Kb, 2.2 Kb, and 620 bp for rrs, katGII, and sodA respectively ( Figure 3).
The amounts of radioactive signals corresponding to kat-GII, and sodA genes in each lane were also quantified and normalized with the amount of radioactivity obtained using the rrs as a probe (see Additional file 1 for the com- In order to determine more accurately the amount of the transcripts of M. fortuitum in response to oxidative stress, qRT-PCR technique was applied to quantify the mRNAs. The transcription of sodA, katGII and its putative regulator furAII were analyzed ( Figure 4). The genes under study did not show main variations in the quantity of products in relation to the different H 2 O 2 concentrations applied, as well as in relation to the duration of the treatment. Again, the only significant change was detected at the highest concentration tested (20 mM H 2 O 2 ). At this concentration, the highest level of katGII, furAII and sodA expressions corresponded to the culture treated with H 2 O 2 during 30 min. Compared to the control culture, katGII and furAII mRNA levels product increased in this point more than twenty and fifteen fold respectively. The products corresponding to sodA suffered a three-fold increase in this same point of analysis (Figure 4).
Under other H 2 O 2 concentrations tested (0.02 mM, 0.2 mM and 2 mM) the mRNA levels of katGII, furAII and sodA either increased to a lesser extent or remain unchanged with the duration of the treatment (Figure 4).

Viability of M. fortuitum under different H 2 O 2 stress treatment
To analyse the influence of the stress on the viability of the M. fortuitum, we determined the colony forming units (CFUs) of each of the cultures ( Figure 5). No main differences were found when controls and test cultures were compared, indicating that changes detected at the mRNA and proteins levels were not related to changes in the bacterial viability.

Discussion
Mycobacteria are ubiquitous bacteria and are therefore exposed to a wide range of environmental conditions, including animals and humans. One of these conditions is the host stress response which includes induction of reactive oxygen intermediates (ROI) against which mycobacteria synthesize enzymes such as superoxide dismutases, catalases and peroxidases. This work studies these enzymatic responses in the opportunistic pathogen M. fortuitum growing in the presence of hydrogen peroxide measured using real-time PCR to quantify mRNA specific products corresponding to genes sodA, katGII and furAII involved in the oxidative stress response.
The development of a reliable qRT-PCR method requires corrections for experimental sample variations, such as reverse transcription efficiency. Those variations are best controlled by the inclusion of an internal reference stand-ard. Ideally this reference standard should have a constant expression under each of the experimental conditions [50]. Moreover, validation of the internal control is recommended when designing quantitative gene expression studies [50].
We have previously reported that the first promoter of the rrnA operon (rrnA-P1) gave better results in M. fortuitum [45] than sigA and 16S rRNA, the standards more frequently used in M. tuberculosis [40,43]. This study has tested this product for suitability as reference standard in the study of the oxidative stress response of M. fortuitum.
The primer extension results showed that the product of the rrnA-P1 promoter was synthesized at a low and constant level when M. fortuitum cultures were placed under oxidative stress (Figure 2a). Experiments conducted to validate rrnA-P1 as reference standard in qRT-PCR ( Figure  2b) found no statistically significant changes (p = 0.445), in expression levels during several of the experimental conditions. It was concluded therefore that rrnA-P1 is a suitable reference standard for qRT-PCR studies of M. fortuitum growing under oxidative stress.
In contrast to the single promoter previously detected upstream of furA and katG genes of M. tuberculosis [30,31], two promoters were identified in the M. fortuitum genome upstream of furAII, katGII and sodA (Table 1a). furAII and Northern blot analysis of the sodA, katGII and rrs under hydrogen-peroxide treatment katGII genes were co-transcribed in M. fortuitum in a similar manner to M. tuberculosis [30,33], showing the previously described conserved organization of those genes among mycobacteria [29]. Recently, it has been demonstrated in M. smegmatis that the single transcript containing furA and katG is processed to originate two different transcripts, one covering furA and the second covering katG [51], that result explain why furA-katG co-transcripts were not detected in this species previously [32]. Nevertheless the occurrence of a similar phenomenon in M. fortuitum cannot be excluded, differently to M. smegmatis, furAII-katGII co-transcripts were detected in M. fortuitum supporting that a different transcriptional organization could occurs in this last mycobacteria.
Several genomes of mycobacterial species have been sequenced or are in progress [52], including that of the rapidly growing mycobacteria M. smegmatis (strain mc 2 155). This strain is used frequently in the study of mycobacteria, because of its rapid growth, and low biosafety requirements. A search of the M. smegmatis genomeidentified three putative katG genes. Two of these are associated with a corresponding furA gene immediately upstream, including a Fur-A box in one of them. Also of note is that the third katG gene has a long deletion in its 5' end (190 nucleotides), which could explain the lack of the sequence corresponding to a paired furA gene upstream.

Studies in M. tuberculosis have clearly established that Fur-
A is a negative regulator of the katG expression in myco-bacteria [29,33]; this regulation is mediated by the FurAbox identified upstream of the furA gene in the region corresponding to the -35 promoter sequence, also known as the AT-rich sequence. The linkage of FurA to the FurA-box is inhibited in the presence of hydrogen peroxide thus allowing the transcription of the downstream genes. Sala et al. [33] have analyzed the FurA box of M. smegmatis, which presumably included the single furA-katG copy associated with this regulatory sequence. In this work we identify that AT-rich sequence 16 nucleotides upstream the furAII start codon of M. fortuitum (Table 1b). This sequence includes the -10 box corresponding to the P2 promoter identified (Table 1). Similarly to M. smegmatis, only one of the two furA-katG tandem genes of M. fortuitum has a sequence equivalent to the FurA box upstream.
By using qRT-PCR, we observed that the influence of hydrogen peroxide in the level of expression of katGII and furAII of M. fortuitum differs from other mycobacteria [29,31,33,53] by not showing variation in the protein and mRNA levels of these genes when M. fortuitum was treated with up to 2 mM hydrogen peroxide (Figures 1, 3 and 4). These results could indicate that M. fortuitum appears to be more resistant to the hydrogen peroxide stress than other mycobacterial species.
We did find significant changes however in the stress response in cultures of M. fortuitum when treated with 20 mM H 2 O 2 . Under such conditions, the mRNA levels of the two genes (katGII and furAII) increased significantly, and the level of sodA mRNA rose to its higher level after 30 minutes of treatment ( Figure 4). Considering also that only a low level of mRNA could be detected when cultures were treated with 20 mM of H 2 O 2 during 60 and 120 minutes (Figure 4), we hypothesized that 20 mM H 2 O 2 may be deleterious for the bacteria, however M. fortuitum cultures studied under stress found no decrease in CFU under each of the conditions tested ( Figure 5). We conclude therefore that the changes detected in genes related to the stress response ( Figure 4) are not associated to changes in the viability of the bacteria, however they could indicate a compensatory reaction, at the transcriptional level, to the decrease detected at the protein level ( Figure 1

Conclusion
Our results indicate that mycobacteria differ in their response against oxidative stress. The opportunistic pathogen M. fortuitum is more resistant to hydrogen peroxide than the main pathogen M. tuberculosis and the sapro- This work also demonstrated the suitability of the noncoding region (pre-rrnA-P1) as reference standard in the quantification of the transcriptional activity of genes associated to oxidative stress in M. fortuitum. The reference product applied (pre-rrnA-P1) is related to the ribosomal RNA, a bacterial component frequently used as reference in the analysis of the bacterial transcriptional activity.

Bacterial strain and growth conditions
M. fortuitum ATCC 6841 T was maintained on Lowenstein Jensen at 4°C for short-term storage and 40% glycerol at -70°C for long-term storage.
Three different cultures of M. fortuitum were grown at 37°C until exponential phase (OD = 0.6-0.8 U) in 100 ml of Sauton broth [54]. Hydrogen peroxide (H 2 O 2 ) was then added to obtain 0.02 to 20 mM final concentrations. Cells were further incubated at 37°C with shaking for 1/2 h, 1 h and 2 h, per each H 2 O 2 concentration. Total RNA and proteins were purified from the cultures (75 ml and 25 ml respectively) following to the treatment with hydrogen peroxide. Untreated cultures were also tested as reference.
Viability of bacteria recovered from the cultures was checked, by determining the colony forming units (CFUs) on Middlebrook 7H10 petri dishes. To reduce possible variation introduced by individual inocula over the several sets of cultures, a separate untreated control culture was included for each H 2 O 2 concentration tested.

Protein isolation and analysis of the protein activity
The protein extracts were prepared by vigorous mixing of bacterial cells in the presence of 0.15-0.212 mm of diameter glass beads (SIGMA) during three sequential pulses of 45 s at 4 m/s in a Fast-Prep (Savant-Instruments). Bacterial extracts were centrifuged and the supernatants were recovered and stored at -70°C. The analysis of the extracts was made by Polyacrilamide Gel Electrophoresis (PAGE). Activity gels were performed in non-denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (ND-PAGE) [55], 10% and 15% [wt/vol] ND-PAGE were applied for catalase and peroxidase and superoxide dismutase analysis respectively. Catalase and peroxidase activities of the mycobacterial extracts were examined by the double-staining method as described previously [56]. Superoxide dismutase activity was examined as described previously [57,58]. Densitometry of the activity bands was determined directly on the gels using ID-Manager (TDI) for comparative purposes.

RNA isolation
Mycobacterial cultures were collected, and total RNA isolated as described previously [59]. Quality of the RNA isolation was checked by gel electrophoresis followed by quantification in spectrophotometer [55].

Analysis of precursors rRNA (pre-rrn) by primer extension
The ribosomal promoter usage of M. fortuitum in Sauton cultures, treated and untreated with H 2 O 2 , was determined using the primer extension (PE) procedure. The primer JY15 (Table 2) was end labelled with [γ-32P]ATP by T4 polynucleotide kinase, and primer extension was carried out with Avian Myeloblastosis Virus (AMV) reverse transcriptase (Promega) as described previously [59]. PE experiments were performed with 25 μg of total RNA per sample. Transcriptional products, corresponding to each rrn promoter, were quantified in the gels by using an Instant Imager system (Packard-Izasa).

Identification of transcription starts points using RNAse Protection Assay
RNase protection assay (RPA) was carried out as described previously [60]. The RPA method requires previous preparation of a radiolabeled RNA probe complementary to the RNA transcript by transcription of a minigene corresponding to the region under analysis [61]. Minigenes were synthesized by PCR amplification of the M. fortuitum corresponding genomic regions by using oligonucleotides described in Table 2.
Radiolabelled transcription products were obtained by using the Riboprobe kit (Promega) as specified by the manufacturer; this yielded probes of 324, 292 and 177 nucleotides for sodA, katGII and furAII genes respectively. The products were purified on a polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (6% [wt/vol] polyacrylamide) sequencing gel. The appropriate bands were excised and eluted as described previously [60].
Hybridization was carried out in PES buffer [60], with radiolabeled samples (2.5 × 10 5 cpm) and 20 μg of DNAfree RNA; the reaction products were digested with different amounts of an RNase cocktail (Ambion). Stock RNase cocktail comprises both RNase T1 (20 U/ul) and RNase A (1 μg/μl), and an optimum concentration (up to a 10-fold dilution) was established for use in the RNA protection assays.
Products of both primer extension and RNase protection assays were analyzed by electrophoresis through 6% (wt/ vol) polyacrylamide-8 M urea sequencing gels. Radioactive products were located by autoradiography either at 20°C or at -70°C using an intensifying screen. The gels were calibrated with the products of appropriate DNAsequencing reactions. DNA sequences were determined by the dideoxy chain termination procedure with [α-35S]dATP [55]. The putative promoter regions (-10 and -35 boxes) were determined ( Table 1).

Analysis of furAII-katGII region
The cDNA from M. fortuitum under the different stresses was analysed by PCR using the primers furAII-Fo and P1.1 (

Analysis of mRNA by Northern blot
Northern blot analysis was performed by fractionation of 20 to 30 μg of total RNA samples on a 1.5% agarose gel containing 6.6% formaldehyde. RNA ladder (0.24 to 9.5 kb; Gibco BRL) was used as the molecular size standard. The gels were transferred to a nylon membrane (Hybond-N; Amersham) by capillary blotting in 20× SSC (1× SSC is 0.15 M NaCl plus 0.015 M sodium citrate), and further cross-linked by UV irradiation [55].
The membranes were hybridized with three probes: kat-GII, sodA and the 16S rRNA (rrs) genes sequentially. The probes were prepared by standard PCR. Amplifications were performed on M. fortuitum chromosomal DNA (100 ng) in a final volume of 50 μl containing 1 μM of each primer and 1 U of Taq polymerase (Amplitaq Gold, Roche). All amplifications were carried out as follows: 36 cycles of 1 min at 95°C; 45 s at the annealing temperature ( Table 2); and 1 min at 72°C, with subsequent 10 min final extension at 72°C. The primers used amplify the coding regions of the corresponding gene. Primers characteristics, annealing temperatures, and sizes of each amplicon are indicated in the Table 2. Hibridizations were made with 90 ng of each PCR product labeled with 32 P α-dCTP using Megaprime DNA labeling system (Amersham) at 65°C overnight. Standard procedures were used for both hybridization and washes [55]. Filters were spread out and rehybridized with the three probes sequentially. The radioactivity hybridized for each gene was quantified on the filter using an Instant Imager system (Packard-Izasa) and also detected by exposition of the membranes to X-ray films. Data derived from hybridization with the rrs gene were used as standard to normalize the amounts of RNA fixed on the filter.

Analysis of mRNA by qRT-PCR
One hundred ng of the mycobacterial RNA isolated was reverse transcribed by using 30 U AMV reverse transcriptase and random primer hexamers (Promega). The absence of DNA following DNase treatment was checked by performing conventional PCR using FoPCL1 and cKK4 ( Real-time PCR was carried out using a capillary PCR instrument (Light Cycler; Roche). The amplification of the target sequence was detected using SYBR green Conditions were used as follows: LightCycler Fast Start DNA master SYBR Green I reagent (1 μl) was supplemented with 3.5 mM (final concentration) MgCl 2 and 0.5 μM of each primer in 7 μl of volume. Sample cDNA (3 μl) was added to the mix. The PCR cycling programme was as follows: denaturizing, 1 cycle of 95°C for 10 min with a transition rate of 20°C/s; amplification, 45 cycles at 95°C for 0 s, the corresponding annealing temperature for each product ( Table 2) for 5 s and an extension at 72°C for 10 s with a single fluorescence acquisition, in all the cases the transition rate was 20°C/s. Specificity of the reaction was checked by analysis of the melting curve of the final amplified product. The oligonucleotides used in qRT-PCR are indicated in the Table 2. In all cases, the negative control was undetectable, because the PCR experiments were stopped before its fluorescence increased.

qRT-PCR data analysis
The qRT-PCR data were plotted as the fluorescence signal versus the cycle number. An arbitrary threshold was set at the midpoint of the log of fluorescent level versus cycle number plot. The Ct value is defined as the cycle number at which the fluorescent level crosses this threshold. In the present study, the fold change in the cDNA amounts was calculated from the formula 2 -ΔΔCt (Applied Biosystem User Bulletin). Using the 2 -ΔΔCt method, the data are presented as the fold change in gene expression normalized to an endogenous reference gene and relative to the untreated control. This calculation transforms the logarithmic Ct data to a linear value. Error of the data was calculated by converting the data from logarithmic to linear using the expression 2 -Ct . Raw C t values falsely represents the error and should be avoided [50]. For the untreated control sample, ΔΔC t equals zero, therefore by definition, the fold change in gene expression relative to the untreated control is one. For the treated samples, 2 -ΔΔCt indicates the fold change in gene expression relative to the control [38]. The fold change in cDNA (per each target gene) relative to the rrnA-P1 control [45] was determined as follows: fold change = 2 -ΔΔCt ; where ΔΔCt = (Ct Target -Ct rrnA-P1 ) Sample -(Ct Target -Ct rrnA-P1 ) Control . The sample corresponds to each H 2 O 2 treated cultures, and controls are the untreated cultures in the formula. According to Winer [62] the relative quantification of gene expression by using the 2 -ΔΔCt method correlates with the absolute gene quantification obtained using standard curves. The statistical significance of data was determined by applying oneway analysis of variance.
Publish with Bio Med Central and every scientist can read your work free of charge