Antibiotics influence the toxicity of the delta endotoxins of Bacillus thuringiensis towards the cotton bollworm, Helicoverpa armigera

Background The cotton bollworm, Helicoverpa armigera is one of the most important crop pests worldwide. It has developed high levels of resistance to synthetic insecticides, and hence, Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) formulations are used as a safer pesticide and the Bt genes have been deployed in transgenic crops for controlling this pest. There is an apprehension that H. armigera might develop resistance to transgenic crops in future. Therefore, we studied the role of gut microbes by eliminating them with antibiotics in H. armigera larvae on the toxicity of Bt toxins against this pest. Results Commercial formulation of Bt (Biolep®) and the pure Cry1Ab and Cry1Ac toxin proteins were evaluated at ED50, LC50, and LC90 dosages against the H. armigera larvae with and without antibiotics (which removed the gut microbes). Lowest H. armigera larval mortality due to Bt formulation and the Bt toxins Cry1Ab and Cry1Ac was recorded in insects reared on diets with 250 and 500 μg ml−1 diet of each of the four antibiotics (gentamicin, penicillin, rifampicin, and streptomycin), while the highest larval mortality was recorded in insects reared on diets without the antibiotics. Mortality of H. armigera larvae fed on diets with Bt formulation and the δ-endotoxins Cry1Ab and Cry1Ac was inversely proportional to the concentration of antibiotics in the artificial diet. Nearly 30% reduction in larval mortality was observed in H. armigera larvae from F1 to F3 generation when the larvae were reared on diets without antibiotics (with gut microbes) and fed on 0.15% Bt or 12 μg Cry1Ab or Cry1Ac ml−1 diet, indicating development of resistance to Bt in the presence of gut microflora. However, there were no differences in larval mortality due to Bt, Cry1Ab or Cry1Ac across generations in insects when they were reared on diets with 250 μg of each antibiotic ml−1 diet (without gut microflora). Conclusions The results suggested that antibiotics which eliminated gut microflora influenced the toxicity of Bt towards H. armigera, and any variation in diversity and abundance of gut microflora will have a major bearing on development of resistance to Bt toxins applied as foliar sprays or deployed in transgenic crops for pest management.


Background
The cotton bollworm, Helicoverpa armigera (Hubner) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) is the most damaging pest of cotton, grain legumes, cereals, vegetables, fruit crops, and forest trees in Asia, Africa, Australia, and the Mediterranean Europe. It is a polyphagous insect that causes an estimated loss of US$2 billion in different crops worldwide [1]. Helicoverpa armigera control is currently heavily based on insecticide use, and it has developed high levels of resistance to commonly used insecticides [2]. To overcome this problem, transgenic crops expressing Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) (Berliner) toxin proteins have been deployed on a large scale for pest management worldwide, that has resulted in a considerable reduction in pesticide use and increased crop production and profitability [3].
Bacillus thuringiensis is a spore forming bacterium that produces crystal proteins (Cry proteins), which are toxic to many species of insects [4,5]. In Lepidoptera, specificity to Bt Cry toxins is due to alkaline pH of the mid gut, which is essential for conversion of protoxin to active toxin form [6][7][8]. However, increasing use of Bt as a conventional insecticide and large-scale cultivation of Bt-transgenic crops may lead to evolution of resistance in H. armigera populations to Bt toxins. Therefore, there is a need to develop strategies to manage development of resistance to Bt toxins, taking into account the various resistance and/or detoxification mechanisms involved in the target and non-target insect pests in different eco-systems.
Development of resistance to Bt toxins has largely been attributed to the extent of binding of Bt toxin proteins to brush border membrane vesicles. However, the toxicity of Bt toxins to insects also depends on the enteric bacteria such as Escherichia coli (Migula) and Enterobacter sp. that normally reside in the insect mid gut [9]. There is considerable variation in the susceptibility of H. armigera larvae to Bt toxins from different locations, and from different host plants [10], which may be due to variation in gut microflora involved in insect nutrition, and potentiation/degradation of Bt toxin proteins in the insect mid gut. Therefore, diversity and population intensity of the enteric bacteria in the mid gut will have a bearing on the insect susceptibility to Bt toxins deployed in transgenic crops for pest management.
Interactions of gut microflora with infectious pathogens and toxins of pathogen or toxins of plant origin have been studied in many organisms, including Crustacea, Mollusca, Echinodermata [11], gypsy moth, butterflies [12], and rats [13]. The crystal proteins of B. thuringiensis var alesti have shown little lethality to cabbage looper larvae, Trichoplusia ni (Hub.) reared on diets containing chlortetracycline at a concentration of 130 ppm [14]. Addition of chlortetracycline hydrochloride in the artificial diet decreased the biological activity of HD-1 strain of B. thuringiensis by 2.4 -67.1 times against 4-day-old larvae of T. ni, Heliothis virescens (F.), and Ostrinia nubilalis (Hub.) [15]. Presence of either bacterial spores or vegetative cells of E. coli several forest epiphytic bacteria significantly increased the biological activity of Bt toxins CryIAa and CryIAc against the gypsy moth, Lymantria dispar (L.) [16]. Bacillus thuringiensis resulted in 63 to100% mortality in Vanesa cardui L., Manduca sexta (L.), Pieris rapae (L.), and H. virescens reared on diets without antibiotics, but only 0 to 10% mortality was recorded when the larvae were reared on diets amended with antibiotics [17]. Antibiotics reduced the populations of gut bacteria below detectable limits, except in H. virescens, which had detectable bacteria prior to treatment with Bt toxins. The reduction in insect mortality was associated with reduced populations of Enterococcus and Enterobactor species from the mid guts of the larvae [9]. Re-establishment of Enterobactor sp., which resides in the insect mid gut, restored the toxicity of Bt toxins [9,17]. However, subsequent studies suggested that reduction in Bt toxicity was not due to removal of gut bacteria, but due the effect of the antibiotics [18][19][20]. However, some of these studies used a different methodology, wherein, the antibiotics aureomycin and ampicillin were administered post Bt treatment. The aseptic larvae that were exposed to the antibiotics during the bioassay or continuously exposed to the antibiotics died more slowly when treated with Bt. However, the larvae administered with a cocktail of antibiotics conferred resistance to L. dispar against Bt [20]. Bacillus cereus (Fr. & Fr.) strains secreting antibiotics synergised Bt infection in the diamond back moth, Plutella xylostella L., but at levels lower than reported earlier [21]. Ingestion of antibiotic secreting strains reduced the abundance of gut microflora regardless of the genotype, reduced the densities of enteric isolates of the gut bacterium, Enterobactor sp., suggesting that secretion of antibiotics in the mid gut synergises the Bt infection by reducing the abundance of commensal gut microflora.
Elimination of gut microbial community by oral administration of antibiotics significantly decreased the insecticidal activity of Bt, and re-establishment of an Enterobacter sp., that normally resides in the mid gut, restored the Bt-mediated toxicity. However, B. thuringiensis is unable to grow in the insect hemocoel [22,23], suggesting that other microbes residing the insect gut play an important role in biological activity of Bt toxins against different insect pests. Because of the profound effect of antibiotics through elimination of gut microbes on the toxicity of Bt toxin proteins, it is important to study these interactions to understand the underlying mechanisms of potentiation and/or degradation of Cry toxins by gut microflora to unravel the possible evolution of various mechanisms of resistance to Bt used as pesticide sprays or deployed in transgenic crops for pest management.

Results
Effect of different concentrations of antibiotics on the mortality of H. armigera larvae due to Bt toxins Bt formulation The mortality of H. armigera larvae due to Bt at LC 50 (0.15%) (Y = 72.67 -7.58x, R 2 = 90.65%; where Y = larval mortality, x = Bt concentration, and R 2 = coefficient of determination, i.e. percentage variation in larval mortality explained by antibiotic concentrations) and LC 90 (0.95%) (Y = 87.77 -8.93x , R 2 = 90.74%) concentrations decreased with an increase in the dosage of antibiotics from 1.95 to 500 μg ml −1 ( Figure 1A). The Bt formulation at the ED 50 levels did not cause any larval mortality. There were no significant differences in mortality of H. armigera larvae reared on diets with different amounts of the antibiotic mixture without Bt, suggesting that antibiotics did not result in any adverse effects on the insect larvae. Bt formulation at LC 90 level resulted in 10.00% larval mortality in insects reared on diets with 250 and 500 μg of each antibiotic ml −1 diet as compared to 83.33% mortality in larvae reared on diets without antibiotics, suggesting that elimination of the gut microflora by antibiotics decreased the toxicity of Bt towards the larvae of H. armigera.

Cry1Ab
The H. armigera larval mortality due to Cry1Ab toxin at the LC 50 (12 μg ml −1 diet) (Y = 65.78 -6.75x, R 2 = 91.26%) and LC 90 (35 μg ml −1 diet) (Y = 91.78 -9.89x, R 2 = 89.87%) concentrations decreased with an increase in the dosage of antibiotics from 1.95 to 500 μg ml −1 ( Figure 1B). Cry1Ab at the ED 50 level did not cause any larval mortality. There were no significant differences in the mortality of H. armigera larvae reared on diets with different amounts of the antibiotic mixture, but without Cry1Ab. Highest mortality of 86.67% was observed in H. armigera larvae reared on diets with LC 90 level of the Cry1Ab toxin, but without antibiotics, whereas 6.67% larval mortality was recorded when the insects were reared on diets with 250 and 500 μg of each antibiotic ml −1 diet with 35 μg ml −1 diet of Cry 1Ab toxin. The antibiotics decreased the activity of Cry1Ab by eliminating the gut microflora that possibly secreted enzymes involved in potentiation/detoxification of Bt toxins.

Effect of different concentrations of antibiotics on weight gain by the larvae of H. armigera in artificial diets amended with Bt toxins Bt formulation
The weights of the H. armigera larvae increased with an increase in the antibiotic concentration, but without Bt (Y = 163.08 + 19.02x, R 2 = 90.98%). Similar increase in larval weights was observed in H. armigera larvae reared on diets with Bt at the ED 50 level (Y = 111.07 + 16.75x, R 2 = 94.73%) (Figure 2A). The weights of the H. armigera larvae also increased with an increase in the amounts of the antibiotics in the artificial diets + Bt at the LC 50 level, although the larval weights were quite low (Y = 10.01 + 1.62x, R 2 = 86.11%). Similar trends in increase in larval weights were also observed in insects reared on diets with Bt at the LC 90 level along with antibiotics. However, the larval weights were quite low. The larval weights were lowest (5.71 mg per larva) in insects reared on diets without antibiotics + 0.95% Bt, while maximum larval weights (358.61 mg per larva) were recorded in insects reared on diets with 500 μg of each antibiotic ml −1 diet, but without Bt, suggesting that antibiotics decreased the biological activity of Bt formulation against the larvae of H. armigera.

Cry1Ab
The weights of the H. armigera larvae increased with an increase in the antibiotic concentration in the artificial diet without Cry1Ab in the artificial diet (Y = 173.91 + 5.22x, R 2 = 83.81%) ( Figure 2B). Similar increase in weights of H. armigera larvae was also observed in insects reared on diets with Cry1Ab at the ED 50 level (4 μg ml −1 diet) (Y = 90.49 + 10.89x, R 2 = 93.53%). The weights of the H. armigera larvae also increased with an increase in the amounts of the antibiotics in diets + Cry1Ab at 12 μg ml −1 diet, but the larval weights were quite low (Y = 5.25 + 0.99x, R 2 = 94.40%). The H. armigera larvae weighed only 1.70 mg per larvae when reared on diets with 1.95 μg of each antibiotic ml −1 diet + 35 μg Cry1Ab ml −1 diet as compared to 234.3 mg per larva in insects reared on diets with 250 μg of each antibiotic ml −1 , but without Cry1Ab.

Cry1Ac
The weights of the H. armigera larvae increased with an increase in the antibiotic concentration without Cry1Ac in the artificial diet (Y = 93.06 + 4.05x, R 2 = 90.51%) ( Figure 2C). Similar increase in weights of H. armigera larvae was also observed in insects reared on diets with Cry1Ac at the ED 50 level (4 μg ml −1 diet) (Y = 56.58 + 4.78x, R 2 = 87.21%). The weights of the H. armigera larvae also increased with an increase in the amounts of the antibiotics in the artificial diets having Cry1Ac at 12 μg ml −1 diet, but the rate of increase was quite low (Y = 4.36 + 1.01x, R 2 = 78.46%). The larval weights were significantly lower (2.66 mg) in insects reared on diets with 1.95 μg of each antibiotic ml −1 + 35 μg Cry1Ac ml −1 , and on diets without antibiotics + 35 μg Cry1Ac ml −1 (2.82 mg) as compared to 132.03 mg in the larvae reared on diets with 250 μg of each antibiotic ml −1 diet, but without Cry1Ac.  Figure 3A). The interaction effects were also significant in F 1 (Fp = 18.9**), F 2 (Fp = 21.3**), and F 3 (Fp = 19.4**) generations. The larval mortality varied from 3.33 to 6.67% through F 1 to F 3 generation when the H. armigera larvae were reared on diets with 250 μg antibiotics + 0.15% Bt as compared from 60.00% mortality in F 1 generation and 30.00% mortality in the F 3 generation in larvae reared on diets without antibiotics + 0.15% Bt, suggesting that gut microflora influenced the susceptibility of H. armigera to Bt toxins across generations.
Effect of antibiotics on weight gain by H. armigera larvae on diets with and without Bt toxins across three generations Bt formulation Incorporation of antibiotic mixture into the artificial diet resulted in significant differences in weights of H. armigera larvae reared on diets with and without Bt in F 1 Figure 2 Effect of antibiotics in the artificial diet on the weights of Helicoverpa armigera larvae due to Bt-formulation (A), and the toxin proteins Cry1Ab (B) and Cry1Ac (C).

Figure 3
Effect of antibiotics (250 μg each of gentamicin, penicillin, rifampicin, and streptomycin ml −1 diet) on mortality of Helicoverpa armigera larvae with LC 50 concentration of Bt-formulation (A), and the toxin proteins Cry1Ab (B) and Cry1Ac (C). LC 50 = Effective dose to cause 50% larval mortality. F 1 , F 2 , and F 3 = Helicoverpa armigera generations exposed to antibiotics.  Figure 4A). The interaction effects between Bt x antibiotic treatments were non-significant. The larval weights declined from 181.3 mg in F 1 generation to 112.0 mg in the F 3 generation when the larvae were reared on diets without antibiotics as compared to 217.8 mg in F 1 and 122.9 mg in F 3 generation on diets with antibiotics.

Cry1Ab
Addition of antibiotics resulted in significant differences in H. armigera larval weights on diets with and without Cry1Ab in F 1 (Fp = 72.5*), F 2 (Fp = 130.5*), and F 3 (Fp = 91.9*) generations, but the antibiotic and Bt interaction effects were non-significant ( Figure 4B). The larval weights decreased from 190.62 mg in F 1 generation to 106.80 mg in the F 3 generation in the larvae reared on diets without antibiotics as compared to 206.3 mg in F 1 and 115.3 mg in F 3 generation in larvae reared on diets with antibiotics.

Cry1Ac
The larval weights differed significantly in larvae of H. armigera reared on diets with Cry1Ac, with and without antibiotics in F 1 (Bt: Fp = 101.9**), F 2 (Bt: Fp = 52.6*), and F 3 (Bt: Fp = 52.2*) generations ( Figure 4C). The interaction effects between Cry1Ac x antibiotics were non-significant. There was a significant reduction in larval weights from 164.4 mg in F 1 generation to 94.1 mg in F 3 generation in larvae reared on diets without antibiotics as compared to 182.4 mg in F 1 and 121.2 mg in F 3 generation in larvae reared on diets with antibiotics.

Discussion
Microorganisms play an important role in physiology and nutrition of insects [24][25][26][27], and also provide protection against infectious pathogens and toxins of pathogen or plants in many organisms [11][12][13]. In the present studies, we studied the role of gut microbes in H. armigera on the biological activity of Bt toxins by using antibiotics to eliminate the gut microflora. Commercial Bt formulation and the toxin proteins Cry1Ab and Cry1Ac induced larval mortality was reduced significantly when the larval diet was amended with antibiotics in a dose-dependent manner. Mortality of insects fed with Bt toxins was inversely proportional to the antibiotic concentration. Decrease in microbial population with an increase in the dosage of the antibiotics resulted in a proportionate decrease in larval mortality. Lowest larval mortalities were recorded in insects reared on diets with 500 and 250 μg of each antibiotic ml −1 diet along with LC 50 concentrations of Bt formulation and Cry toxins, while maximum mortality was recorded in insects reared on diets without antibiotics + LC 90 concentration of Bt formulation/Cry toxins. Mortality of gypsy moth, L. dispar and cabbage looper, T. ni fed on Bt amended diet has also been reported to be inversely proportional to the antibiotic concentration [9,14,28]. Jarosz [29] observed that Streptococcus faecalis (Andrewes & Horder) in guts of G. mellonella larvae suppressed the bacteria ingested with food by producing bacteriocin -an antibiotic like substance having a narrow range of bactericidal activity, and by releasing a lysozyme like enzyme. The reduction in mortality due to Bt was attributed to reduced populations of gut bacteria, Enterococcus and Enterobacter species. Re-establishment of Enterobacter sp. in larvae reared on antibiotic-amended diet restored the biological activity of Bt [9].
The growth of Bt drops to below detectable limits in the insect hemolymph after 6 h, whereas Enterobacter sp. and E. coli grow rapidly in larval hemolymph, indicating that the enteric bacteria are needed for septicaemia associated with Bt toxicity. Bt does not grow in the insect hemocoel, indicating that Bt alone is not responsible for septicaemia [23,30]. However, enteric bacteria alone do not induce mortality, suggesting that Bt enables them to reach the hemocoel by making the gut epithelium permeable [9]. These findings are further supported by the earlier observations that the Bt spores are absent from the insect hemocoel until very late in the infection process, and frequently do not appear until well after the death of the insect [22,[31][32][33] Incorporation of Pseudomonas and Acinetobacter isolates in the mosquito blood meal result in an increased susceptibility of Culex quiquefasciatus Say to the Japanese encephalitis virus [34].
Role of gut microflora in the susceptibility of H. armigera larvae to Bt was also studied across three generations by rearing the insects on artificial diet amended with antibiotics with and without Bt toxins. There was nearly 30% reduction in larval mortality from F 1 to F 3 generations when the larvae were reared on diets without antibiotics (with gut microbes) and fed on 0.15% Bt formulation, 12 μg Cry1Ab ml −1 diet or 12 μg Cry1Ac ml −1 diet. However, when the insects were reared on diets with antibiotics (without gut microflora), there was no significant reduction in insect mortality from F 1 to F 3 generations.
Antibiotics have been reported to reduce the populations of gut microflora in many insect species and the reduction in insect mortality is associated with reduced populations of gut microflora, including Enterococcus and Enterobactor species from the mid guts of the larvae [9,[14][15][16][17]. Re-establishment of Enterobactor sp., which resides in the insect mid gut microbial community, restored the toxicity of Bt toxins [9,17]. Bacillus cereus strains secreting antibiotics also synergise Bt infection in the diamond back moth, P. xylostella [21]. Ingestion of antibiotic secreting strains reduced the abundance of gut microflora, and regardless of the genotype, reduced the densities of enteric isolates of the gut bacterium, Figure 4 Effect of antibiotics (250 μg each of gentamicin, penicillin, rifampicin, and streptomycin ml −1 diet) on weights of Helicoverpa armigera larvae with LC 50 concentration of Bt-formulation (A), and toxin proteins Cry1Ab (B) and cry1Ac (C). LC 50 = Effective dose to cause 50% larval mortality. F 1 , F 2 , and F 3 = Helicoverpa armigera generations exposed to antibiotics.
Enterobactor sp., suggesting that antibiotic secretion in the gut synergises the Bt infection by reducing the abundance of commensal gut microflora. However, some workers have suggested that enteric bacteria did not contribute to insect mortality due to Bt [18][19][20], and the reduction in Bt toxicity was due the effect of the antibiotics on toxicity of Bt toxins. However, they used a different methodology, wherein, the antibiotics aureomycin and ampicillin were administered post Bt treatment. However, the larvae administered with a cocktail of antibiotics conferred resistance to L. dispar against Bt [20]. The aseptic larvae that were exposed continuously or only during the bioassay died slowly when treated with Bt. The weights of H. armigera larvae increased with an increase in antibiotic concentration in the diet, indicating that elimination of gut microbes reduced the biological activity of Bt, but not the larval growth, suggesting that these enteric bacteria do not cause any adverse effects on H. armigera larvae or play a major role in nutrition of H. armigera.
From the foregoing account, it is apparent that antibiotics reduce the activity of gut microflora in the insect mid gut, but the extent and the nature of effect on different species varies with the antibiotic used, administration of the antibiotics (before or after treatment with Bt toxins), dosage and the diversity of gut microflora in different insect species. The diversity of gut microflora varies across host plants on which the insect feeds and the geographical region from where the insects have been collected (Parmasiva, I., Unpublished). The H. armigera populations collected from different host plants and from different regions also exhibit significant differences in their susceptibility to Bt toxins. In the absence of gut microbes (when the larvae were fed on diets with antibiotics for three successive generation), the H. armigera larval mortality due to Bt toxins was drastically reduced as compared to the larvae fed on diets without antibiotics (with gut microbes). Therefore, there is need to study the interaction of antibiotics with Bt toxins, the effect of antibiotics on diversity of gut microflora in insects fed on different host plants and from different regions, identify the microbial species that influence the toxicity of Bt toxins, the enzymes produced, and their role in potentiation of Bt toxins (pro-toxintoxin conversion) and degradation in the insect mid gut. This information will be important to develop strategies for resistance management in Bt-transgenic crops for sustainable crop production and food security.

Conclusions
The toxicity of commercial Bt formulation and the toxin proteins Cry1Ab and Cry1Ac to H. armigera larvae was reduced significantly when fed on diets amended with antibiotics. Mortality of insects fed with Bt toxins was inversely proportional to the antibiotic concentration. There was no selection for resistance to Bt toxins in the absence of gut microflora, suggesting that enteric bacteria will play a major role in evolution of insect populations with resistance to Bt toxins/Bt-transgenic plants. It will be important to know which of these bacterial species are essential for insecticidal activity/detoxification of Bt toxins.

Methods
The larvae of H. armigera were obtained from the laboratory culture maintained at the International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics (ICRISAT), Patancheru, Andhra Pradesh, India. Larvae were reared on chickpea based artificial diet [35] at 27 ± 1°C, and 12 h photoperiod. The neonates were reared for 5 days in groups of 200 to 250 in 200 ml plastic cups containing a 2 to 3 mm layer of artificial diet on the bottom and sides of the cup. Thereafter, the larvae were transferred individually to six cell-well plates (each cell-well 3.5 cm in diameter, 2 cm in depth) to avoid cannibalism. Adults were provided with 10% sucrose or honey solution on a cotton swab for feeding. Diaper liners, which have a rough surface, were provided as a substrate for egg laying. The liners were removed daily, and the eggs sterilized in 2% sodium hypochlorite solution. The liners with eggs were dried under a table fan and then placed inside the plastic cups with artificial diet.
Effect of different concentrations of antibiotics on toxicity of Bt toxins towards H. armigera larvae The role of gut microflora on the biological activity of Bt formulation Biolep®, and pure Cry1Ab and Cry1Ac toxins towards H. armigera was studied by rearing the larvae on artificial diet with a range of concentrations (0, 1.95, 3.91, 7.82, 15.63, 31.25, 62.5, 125, 250, and 500 μg ml −1 diet) of the antibiotic compounds (gentamicin, penicillin, rifampicin, and streptomycin) (Sigma Chemicals, USA). The larvae were reared on artificial diets amended with antibiotics up to second-instar. Upon moulting to the third-instar, the larvae were transferred to sterile artificial diet without antibiotics, but with ED 50 , LC 50 , and LC 90 levels of Bt formulation (0.005, 0.15, and 0.95%, respectively), Cry1Ab (4, 12, and 35 μg ml −1 diet, respectively), and Cry1Ac (4, 12, and 35 μg ml −1 diet, respectively) to H. armigera. Data were recorded on larval mortality and larval weights five days after rearing the insects on the diets amended with Bt, Cry1Ab, or Cry1Ac, corresponding to 10 -day old larvae on the standard artificial diet.
Effect of antibiotics on toxicity of Bt-formulation and toxins Cry1Ab and Cry1Ac towards H. armigera larvae across three generations Role of gut microflora in susceptibility of H. armigera to B. thuringiensis was studied for three generations by rearing the insects on artificial diet amended with antibiotics (gentamicin, penicillin, rifampicin, and streptomycin, 250 μg each antibiotic ml −1 diet). In another treatment, the larvae were reared on artificial diet without antibiotics up to second-instar. Upon moulting to third-instar, the larvae were fed on artificial diet amended with LC 50 levels of Bt formulation (0.15%), Cry1Ab (12 μg ml −1 diet), and Cry1Ac (12 μg ml −1 diet) to H. armigera. Mortality and weights of surviving larvae were recorded 5 days after initiation of experiment. Same protocol was followed for F 2 and F 3 generations.

Data analysis
The data were subjected to analysis of variance. The significance of differences between the treatments was judged by F-test, while the treatment means were compared by least significant difference at P ≤ 0.05. The data on larval mortality across different antibiotic concentrations was subjected to Probit analysis to compute dosageresponse relationship (regression equation).