Human methanogen diversity and incidence in healthy and diseased colonic groups using mcrA gene analysis
© Scanlan et al. 2008
Received: 11 December 2007
Accepted: 20 May 2008
Published: 20 May 2008
Skip to main content
© Scanlan et al. 2008
Received: 11 December 2007
Accepted: 20 May 2008
Published: 20 May 2008
The incidence and diversity of human methanogens are insufficiently characterised in the gastrointestinal tract of both health and disease. A PCR and clone library methodology targeting the mcrA gene was adopted to facilitate the two-fold aim of surveying the relative incidence of methanogens in health and disease groups and also to provide an overview of methanogen diversity in the human gastrointestinal tract.
DNA faecal extracts (207 in total) from a group of healthy controls and five gastrointestinal disease groups were investigated. Colorectal cancer, polypectomised, irritable bowel syndrome and the control group had largely equivalent numbers of individuals positive for methanogens (range 45–50%). Methanogen incidence in the inflammatory bowel disease groups was reduced, 24% for ulcerative colitis and 30% for Crohn's disease. Four unique mcrA gene restriction fragment length polymorphism profiles were identified and bioinformatic analyses revealed that the majority of all sequences (94%) retrieved from libraries were 100% identical to Methanobrevibacter smithii mcrA gene. In addition, mcrA gene sequences most closely related to Methanobrevibacter oralis and members of the order Methanosarcinales were also recovered.
The mcrA gene serves as a useful biomarker for methanogen detection in the human gut and the varying trends of methanogen incidence in the human gut could serve as important indicators of intestinal function. Although Methanobrevibacter smithii is the dominant methanogen in both the distal colon of individuals in health and disease, the diversity of methanogens is greater than previously reported. In conclusion, the low incidence of methanogens in Inflammatory Bowel Disease, the functionality of the methanogens and impact of methane production in addition to competitive interactions between methanogens and other microbial groups in the human gastrointestinal tract warrants further investigation.
The methanogens are a group of microorganisms within the Kingdom Euryarchaeota of the domain Archaea . Methanogenesis is a process confined exclusively to the methanogens and utilises substrates such as hydrogen, CO2, acetate, formate, methanol and methylamines for methane generation. The methanogenic archaea are widely distributed in natural environments including the gastrointestinal tracts of ruminants, termites and humans [2–4]. Studies to date indicated that Methanobrevibacter smithii is the predominant archaeal species present in the human large intestine [2, 5, 6]. and so far only a second methanogenic species Methanosphaera stadtmanae, also a member of the order Methanobacteriales has been isolated from the human intestinal tract .
The reasons underlying methanogen incidence and their seemingly low diversity in human populations are of considerable interest to gastrointestinal microbial ecologists. An increasing interest in the methanogenic populations of the human gastrointestinal tract is also underpinned by their potential role as environmental factors in obesity  and pneumatosis cystoides intestinalis  and any possible association methanogens or methane production may have with gastrointestinal disease. As yet, no pathogenic Archaea have been characterised to date and the aetiological role, if any, methanogens play in disease is unknown [10, 11]. Although no pathogenic archaeal species has been found , they are routinely identified in samples from the sites of oral infections [12–14] leading to speculation that they may be indirectly involved in disease processes by creating environmental conditions to facilitate the growth of microbes involved in pathogenesis.
In methane-producing humans methanogen numbers are approximately 1.6 × 108 to 8 × 109/g faeces [15, 16]. and in non-methanogenic humans 102 to 5 × 106/g faeces . Traditionally, the characterization of methanogens from the human intestinal environment has largely focused on phenotypic, microscopic, biochemical and nutritional classification methodologies [2, 5, 7]. and whilst these techniques are critical to gastrointestinal microbial studies they are time consuming and laborious . Furthermore, molecular techniques for characterising microbial communities are considered more comprehensive and enable a more accurate overview of the diversity and functionality present in the human gastrointestinal tract [18, 19].
This study has undertaken the optimisation of appropriate culture independent methodologies with the aim of investigating and characterising methanogen incidence and diversity in human faecal samples. A PCR and clone library methodology was employed using one set of previously published PCR primers  specific to the α subunit of methyl-coenzyme M reductase (mcrA), a functional gene that catalyzes the terminal step in the formation of methane by methanogens  and a second set of novel primers which were designed to specifically target the mrtA gene (mcrA gene holoenzyme) of Methanosphaera stadtmanae.
High molecular weight DNA, free from PCR inhibitors is critical to PCR analysis  and each DNA sample in this study was tested in order to ensure that a negative mcrA gene or mrtA gene PCR result were not as a consequence of poor DNA extraction and quality. An initial PCR targeting the 16S rRNA gene was used as a control measure for DNA quality and all faecal DNA extracts gave a positive signal for a 16S rRNA gene PCR assay. The mcrA gene was chosen as a proxy for methanogen detection as this gene can be readily amplified from Mbb. smithii (data not shown) which is the dominant methanogen in the human gut [2, 5, 6, 23, 24]. Furthermore, the detection limits of the primers for mcrA gene amplification were calculated and a positive PCR result obtained using the mcrA primer set from spiked samples at cell numbers ≥ 107 cells per gram of faeces using Mbb. smithii PST as the test organism. Therefore, results recorded and reported in this study were obtained from faecal samples where methanogen cell numbers equalled or exceeded 107 cells per gram of faeces making its detection level equivalent to that of the methane breath test  and real-time PCR assay using methanogen specific 16S rRNA gene primers .
Overview of age and number of participants and the percentage of individuals positive for methanogens within each different disease group analysed.
Number of individuals per group (n = 207 total)
Mean age, SD and range
% Methanogen positive (mcrA gene)
Healthy Controls (HC)
25.8 ± 8.3 (range 19–56)
No history of gastrointestinal illness
Crohn's Disease (CD)
41.3 ± 11.9 (range 25–70)
Both remission and relapse (CDAI >150 a) individuals
Ulcerative Colitis (UC)
49.0 ± 12.0 (range 32–70)
Both remission and relapse individuals b
Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS)
44.4 ± 12.8 yrs, (range 24–74)
Diagnosed according to the Rome II criteria c
Colorectal Cancer (CC)
60.3 ± 6.6 yrs, (range 45–70)
In remission, >95% receiving a wide range of medication
53.5 ± 9.1 yrs, (range 30–69)
Pre-cancerous polyps removed
The results from the healthy group reported in this study are also similar to those obtained from a real time-PCR analysis of methanogen incidence and diversity in the human gastrointestinal tract using 16S rRNA gene as a target . Only 12 adults were analysed as part of this study and 5/12 adults (42%) gave a positive PCR result. In the majority of samples analysed in the total study PCR amplicons generated were beyond the quantitative limits of the PCR assay. Furthermore, Mbb. smithii was the predominant sequence obtained from extensive sequence analysis with no Msp.stadtmanae sequences recovered .
Overview of mcrA clone library analysis
Number of Clones analysed (n = 558)
Number of different of RFLP profiles
Preliminary RFLP profile identification of methanogens
Mbb. smithii - RFLP Type A
Mbb. smithii - RFLP Type A
Mbb. smithii - RFLP Type A (19) and Mbb. oralis-Type B (29)
Mbb. smithii - RFLP Type A (46), Mbb. smithii - RFLP Type C (1) and Unknown (related to Methanosalsum zhilinae) - RFLP Type D (1)
Mbb. smithii - RFLP Type A (45) and Mbb. oralis - RFLPType B (3)
Several mismatches to the mrtA gene sequence of Msp.stadtmanae were evident with the mcrA primer set and phylogenetic analysis and tree construction illustrates that although the mrtA gene of Msp. stadtmanae encodes an enzyme of the same function and inhabits the same niche it is phylogenetically distinct from mcrA gene sequences of Mbb. smithii and related clones (see Figure 2). A second set of primers were designed and optimised for mrtA gene amplification serving as a marker for Msp. stadtmanae detection. PCR and clone library analysis indicate that the primers were highly specific for and readily amplified DNA from pure Msp. stadtmanae DNA at concentrations less than 0.01 ng ul-1. However, no positive PCR results were obtained for mrtA gene from faecal DNA extracts in this study. Further analysis of available 16S rRNA gene libraries from published literature [6, 31] and analysis in silico of metagenomic clones libraries generated from human faecal samples also support the idea that Msp. stadtmanae is not a common feature of the human gastrointestinal microbiota. Therefore, it is quite possible that if Msp. stadtmanae was present in any of the faecal samples analysed in this study its concentration was below the detection levels of this novel primer set.
Methanobrevibacter smithii and Msp.stadtmanae are phylogenetically diverse methanogens and the metabolic capacity of both microbes may provide evidence for the predominance of Mbb.smithii in the human gastrointestinal tract. Genome comparisons between both methanogens indicate that Mbb. smithii is more adapted to the gut environment in terms of persistence, metabolic versatility and capacity for genomic evolution . Not only is the Mbb. smithii genome significantly enriched for genes involved in CO2, H2 and formate utilisation during methanogenesis, Mbb. smithii also possesses the capacity for non methanogenic removal of other bacterial fermentation end-products, namely methanol and ethanol. Although both genomes exhibit limited global synteny, Msp.stadtmanae has the most restricted energy metabolism of any archaea studied to date  and can only use hydrogen to reduce methanol to methane. It is possible that this limited substrate range could be a factor in competition between Msp.stadtmanae and other microorganisms such as Mbb. smithii and the sulphate reducing bacteria which also require hydrogen for growth . However, further insight into Msp.stadtmanae incidence and interaction is now possible with this novel primer set which also have application to the rumen gut and other ecosystems where Msp.stadtmanae like sequences have been reported [36, 37]
The functionality of methanogens appears to be strongly associated and facilitated by the presence and activities of other microbial groups [38, 39]. If indeed the carriage of methanogens is dependent upon or supported by other microbial groups and their activities, these differences observed between the methanogen frequency in certain disease and control groups compared to inflammatory bowel disease is quite possibly linked to the reduced bacterial diversity that is routinely reported in this gastrointestinal disease conditions [40–42] Considering these points, it is reasonable to suggest the presence of methanogens in human gastrointestinal tract is part due to the presence of other microbial group or groups with fermentation capacities that generate sufficient H2 and substrates to support methanogenesis in a competitive environment. The presence of such a bacterial population could be present due to genetic host factors, diet, intestinal transit time, stochastic and other environmental factors that would support such an overall symbiotic community. As such the reduced frequency of methanogens evident within the IBD groups could possibly serve as a biomarker of altered microbial diversity and metabolic processes within the human gastrointestinal tract.
This exploration of a functionally significant microbial group provides a comprehensive survey of methanogen incidence and diversity in both health and disease of the human gastrointestinal tract using a culture independent approach. The limited diversity of methanogens as evidenced by the Mbb. smithii dominance of clone libraries and failure to amplify Msp. stadtmanae from faecal samples raises interesting ecological questions on the nature of microbial competition for resources in the human gut. Furthermore, the identification of a mcrA gene sequences only distantly related to cultured methanogens is of significant interest and highlights the necessity of a culture independent approach when surveying diversity of this fastidious group of microorganisms and also the requirement to better our cultivation techniques to gain access to novel and uncultured microbes. In addition, the results of this study have highlighted some important points on the nature of methanogen carriage and their prospect as markers for altered gastrointestinal function. The reduced incidence of hydrogen utilising microbes in IBD could also serve as a biomarker for altered biochemical activities in the intestinal tract of certain individuals and warrants further exploration. It is now possible with the methods outlined in this study that functional analysis of mcrA gene as a proxy for methane production using RNA as a template could have relevance for the further study of clinical conditions related to methanogen carriage and methane production and also the competitive interactions between methanogens and other microbial groups.
A total of 207 faecal samples from individuals within diseased and healthy colonic groups were obtained and faecal samples were stored at -80°C until analyses (see Table 1 for an overview of participants). All samples were stored and processed in the same manner. Samples were thawed on ice and approximately 220 mg of stool was used for DNA extraction using the Qiagen MiniStool kit (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany) as per manufacturer's instructions for pathogen isolation, with an initial bead-beating step of 30 s and heating step of 85°C. DNA concentration was determined using the Nanodrop spectrophotometer. The details of each group are outlined in Table 1. No individuals were receiving or had received antibiotics within three months of faecal sample collection.
Primers 27f and 1492r specific for the bacterial 16S rRNA were used in PCR mixtures containing 50 μl containing 1 X TAE Buffer (20 mM Tris-HCl pH 8.4, 50 mM KCl), 3 mM MgCl2, 200 μM of each deoxynucleoside triphosphate, 1.25 U of Taq polymerase (Invitrogen), 10 pmol of each primer and 5 ng of extracted DNA. PCR was conducted in duplicate in a MJ Research PTC-200 Thermal Cycler and cycling conditions were as follows: 94°C for 5 min initial denaturation, followed by 30 cycles of 94°C for 30 s, 55°C for 40 s and 72°C for 1 min 30 s, with a final extension of 72°C for 10 min. PCR amplicons were analysed by electrophoresis in 1% w/v agarose containing ethidium bromide (0.25 mg ml-1) and 1 X TAE Buffer  with an applied voltage of 5 V cm-1. DNA was visualised by UV illumination (302 nm).
Previously published primers ME1 (5'-GCMATGCARATHGGWATGTC-3') and ME2 (5'-TCATKGCRTAGTTDGGRTAGT-3')  specific for mcrA gene were employed. Both cycling and reagent concentrations for PCR reactions targeting the mcrA gene were according to the methodology of Hales et al., . Genomic DNA from Methanocaldococcus infernus MET, Mbb. smithii (DSM 2374) and Mbb. smithii PST were used as positive PCR controls. PCR amplicons were analysed as previously outlined for 16S rRNA gene PCR and target sequences for mcrA gene were approximately 760 bp.
Analysis in silico of mcrA gene primers and the mrtA gene sequence of Msp. stadtmanae alignments indicated that several nucleotide mismatches were evident between the sequences. A second set of primers for the specific amplification of the mrtA gene from Msp. stadtmanae MCB-3T were designed. Reference mcrA gene sequences and the mrtA gene from Msp. stadtmanae MCB-3T were imported into Bioedit from Genbank. Nucleotide sequences were aligned using CLUSTALW and primers were designed to target two unique sites specific to mrtA gene from Msp. stadtmanae and are as follows; MrtA_for (5' AAA CAA TCA ACC ACG CAC TC 3') and MrtA_rev (5' GTG AGC CCA ATC GAA GGA 3'). Initial PCR procedure was tested and optimised using a gradient MJ Research PTC-200 Thermal Cycler on genomic DNA from Msp. stadtmanae MCB-3T. The primers were also tested on DNA from Methanocaldococcus infernus MET, Mbb. smithii (DSM 2374) and Mbb. smithii PST. PCR amplicons generated from Msp. stadtmanae MCB-3T were also cloned out (using the procedure for mcrA gene cloning) to further assess the specificity of the primer set. Final PCR mixtures for the amplification for the mrtA gene from faecal DNA extractions consisted of 50 μl containing 20 mM Tris-HCl (pH 8.4), 50 mM KCl, 3 mM MgCl2, 50 mM concentrations of each dNTP, 1.25 U of Taq polymerase (Invitrogen), 10 pmol of each primer, and 10 ng of genomic DNA. PCRs were conducted in duplicate in a MJ Research PTC-200 Thermal Cycler and cycling conditions were as follows: 95°C for 5 min initial denaturation, followed by 35 cycles of 94°C for 40 s, 55°C for 40 s and 72°C for 90 s with a final extension of 72°C for 5 min. All PCR reactions were repeated on a separate occasion to verify results. Target sequences were approximately 1170 bp.
Faecal samples that tested negative for mcrA gene products as using PCR protocol as previously outlined were used to conduct spiking experiments in order to determine the limits of detection for each primer set. Liquid pure culture Mbb. smithii (DSM 2374) was obtained from the DSMZ and the numbers of cells per ml were determined using a haemocytometer according to standard procedure. Known number of cells were added to negative faecal samples at concentrations of 109, 108, 107, 106 and 105 cells per g of faecal sample and extracted as previously outlined. A non spiked faecal sample and a pure cell culture of each microbial group were included as controls. All experiments were conducted in duplicate and PCR for mcrA gene amplification was conduced on each extract as previously outlined. DNA from Methanocaldococcus infernus MET and Mbb. smithii (DSM 2374) were included as PCR controls in each experiment.
The results from the mcrA gene PCR were tabulated and the numbers of individuals positive for methanogens are expressed as a percentage of the total number of individuals analysed within each specific group. Fisher's Exact test was used to analyse the statistical significance of the frequency of methanogen carriage from each different disease cohorts compared to the healthy control group.
Four randomly selected individuals per group that gave a positive PCR result for mcrA gene amplification were chosen to generate mcrA gene clone libraries. Four PCR products for each group were pooled and cleaned (using the Qiagen Gel Extraction Kit), before cloning using TOPO® XL PCR Cloning Kit (Invitrogen). Clones were grown overnight on LB agar (1.5% w/v agar) containing kanamycin for selection (50 μg ml-1). Kanamycin resistant colonies were picked and colony PCR was performed. Briefly, the picked colony was suspended in 20 μl of sterile distilled H2O and heated to 95°C for 5 min before adding 1 μl aliquot to each respective PCR mixture as previously described. Products were checked for the correct size insert on 1% (w/v) agarose gel as previously described. Restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) using the enzymes Alu I and Mse I of cloned mcrA PCR products and mcrA gene PCR product of Mbb. smithii (DSM 2374) and Mbb. smithii PST was conducted. RFLP products were electrophoresed for 3 hours at constant 100 V through 2% (w/v) agarose and stained using ethidium bromide.
Nucleotide sequences for mcrA were analysed using the tBLASTx (translated query versus translated database) function of Basic Local Alignment Search Tool (BLAST) . Phylogenetic trees were constructed using relevant mcrA gene sequences in order to highlight phylogenetic relationships between the sequences retrieved in this study and other methanogens. Translated nucleotide sequences for McrA were edited and aligned with relevant sequences obtained from GenBank using the CLUSTALW  function of MEGA 4 . Unambiguously aligned sequence regions were used to construct bootstrap-supported (500 resamplings) phylogenetic trees.
Nucleotide sequence numbers have been deposited in the EMBL Nucleotide Sequence Database under accession no. EMBL: AM921680, EMBL: AM921681, EMBL: AM921683 and EMBL:AM921684.
Thank you to all participants for providing samples for this study and to Dr Caroline Codling for providing additional control faecal DNA extracts. Also, thank you to Prof. Gerhard Gottschalk and Dr Henning Seedorf for kindly providing DNA from Methanosphaera stadtmanae for this study, the donation is greatly appreciated. This research was supported by the Health Research Board of Ireland.
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.